Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Tony Duell via cctalk
On Wed, Feb 20, 2019 at 11:40 PM Warner Losh via cctalk wrote: > At least on the Rainbow the floppy chip is kept in MFM mode all the time, > unless you've written something to hack it to read alien disks. And modified the hardware. On the Rainbow the 'Dden/' pin of the floppy controller chip is

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
> Ability to read MFM data with FM headers (RX50) On 2/20/19 3:40 PM, Warner Losh wrote: The RX50's are MFM encoded. There's no FM anything on it, unless it's that way on all MFM diskettes. Other DEC diskettes may have done this, but RX50's are just higher track density, but old pre IBM-AT

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Chuck Guzis via cctalk
On 2/20/19 3:40 PM, Warner Losh wrote: > The RX50's are MFM encoded. There's no FM anything on it, unless it's > that way on all MFM diskettes. > > Other DEC diskettes may have done this, but RX50's are just higher track > density, but old pre IBM-AT data encoding rate diskettes. > > At least

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Warner Losh via cctalk
On Tue, Feb 19, 2019 at 3:38 PM Chuck Guzis via cctalk < cctalk@classiccmp.org> wrote: > On 2/19/19 2:02 PM, Fred Cisin via cctalk wrote: > > > Ability to read MFM data with FM headers (RX50) > > It's not that simple. There's the matter of "DEC MFM" which encodes a > few bit patterns differently

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Liam Proven via cctalk
On Wed, 20 Feb 2019 at 18:08, Eric Korpela via cctalk wrote: > > Don't forget hard sector CompuColor II, GCR, and variable speed GCR. :) Well, yes, OK, but one step at a time. Step 1: a generic USB floppy controller that allows 5¼" and 8" (and other standard Shugart-interface) FDDs to be

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Eric Korpela via cctalk
On Tue, Feb 19, 2019 at 4:39 PM Chuck Guzis via cctalk < cctalk@classiccmp.org> wrote: > On 2/19/19 3:40 PM, William Sudbrink via cctalk wrote: > > A design that can manage Ohio Scientific as well would be nice. > > Might as well add Victor 9000... > Don't forget hard sector CompuColor II, GCR,

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Adrian Graham via cctalk
Hello folks, I'm coming into this a bit late but a bloke called David Given is working on such a floppy controller right now, it's called Fluxengine and is based around a Cypress microcontroller that connects directly to a floppy drive and is driven by USB. Early days as yet in that it supports

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-20 Thread Ali via cctalk
> By the time that I got out (for other reasons), XenoCopy had not been > profitable for a while. THAT handled files, but the user still had to > deal in other ways with modifications that they needed to the content > of > the files. True, but at that point that is the user's problem. The idea

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Chuck Guzis via cctalk
With all deference to the real collectors, I don't see the objective here. The thing should be NEC 765 compatible? Why? What about non-NEC-based sytems (e.g. the bulk of CP/M and countless other systems that don't use an LSI controller)? Or those systems that permanently already have a

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
I would like to see software for . . . THEN, I would like to see that software as . . . THEN, I would like to see that . . . On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, alan--- via cctalk wrote: What's stopping you from writing it? It's in the queue! Which is longer than my expected remaining lifespan. There are

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread alan--- via cctalk
On 2019-02-19 19:42, Fred Cisin via cctalk wrote: On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Ali wrote: Are we being a little sarcastic or serious? :) A lot of BOTH I would like to see software for flux transition hardware that would extract sectors. THEN, I would like to see that software as a subroutine, with

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread alan--- via cctalk
Doesn't SuperCard Pro already do this? The hardware isn't open source, but the USB control protocol to read and write flux transitions on an entire track is open and well documented. And there are already several tools to exercise the protocol. Sure, one could replicate the hardware work

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Ali wrote: That would make for a very powerful tool but as you pointed out yourself how many users would learn to use it? Unless it is a simple driver that gets loaded and the user has to simply put in a couple of generic parameters, e.g. "device=c:\drives\emudsk.sys

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Ali via cctalk
Fred,> Are we being a little sarcastic or serious? >:)>>A lot of BOTHJust making sure. ;)>I would like to see software for flux >transition hardware that would >extract sectors.>THEN, I would like to see that software as >a >subroutine, with an interface similar to >INT13h.>THEN, I would like

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Paul Koning wrote: I' reminded of the Bordynuik tape reading machine that uses an MR head. Capturing analog flux levels at, say, 10x the nominal flux change density means all the rest is simply digital signal processing. That can be done in real time if you must, but much

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Paul Koning via cctalk
> On Feb 19, 2019, at 8:00 PM, Fred Cisin via cctalk > wrote: > > On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Fred Cisin via cctalk wrote: >> As I see it, flux transition hardware COULD be all that is needed for >> hardware. Emulation of FDC could be done in software with flux transition >> hardware. > > That

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Fred Cisin via cctalk wrote: As I see it, flux transition hardware COULD be all that is needed for hardware. Emulation of FDC could be done in software with flux transition hardware. That should read flux transition plus appropriate control signals for the drive.

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
A design that can manage Ohio Scientific as well would be nice. On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Chuck Guzis via cctalk wrote: Might as well add Victor 9000... It was in my original list :-)

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Ali wrote: Are we being a little sarcastic or serious? :) A lot of BOTH I would like to see software for flux transition hardware that would extract sectors. THEN, I would like to see that software as a subroutine, with an interface similar to INT13h. THEN, I would like

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Chuck Guzis via cctalk
On 2/19/19 3:40 PM, William Sudbrink via cctalk wrote: > A design that can manage Ohio Scientific as well would be nice. Might as well add Victor 9000... --Chuck

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, dwight wrote: Actually, I'd like to see it just read/write flux changes + index marks onto a SD card for later analysis. Building all the smarts into the controller means that some formats will get missed. One can later write translation code for what ever format one has.

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Al Kossow via cctalk
On 2/19/19 2:31 PM, dwight via cctalk wrote: > Actually, I'd like to see it just read/write flux changes + index marks onto > a SD card for later analysis. You want to do the analysis at the time of capture, in case you need to re-read the media, or wiggle the head to try to push off a bit

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
Ability to read MFM data with FM headers (RX50) On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Chuck Guzis via cctalk wrote: It's not that simple. There's the matter of "DEC MFM" which encodes a few bit patterns differently to avoid collision with FM headers. Which is presumably a matter of appropriate code for

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Ali via cctalk
> Actually, I'd like to see it just read/write flux changes + index > marks onto a SD card for later analysis ... > We no longer need proprietary hardware. Well some of us might not and then there is the rest of us who just need a tool that kind of works. I guess the question is "who is your

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread William Sudbrink via cctalk
A design that can manage Ohio Scientific as well would be nice. --- This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software. https://www.avast.com/antivirus

RE: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Ali via cctalk
Fred, Are we being a little sarcastic or serious? :)Honestly, a sw implementation would be interesting but would it work on vintage hw? Or are you suggesting for use only with a modern system? For example here is my dilemma: my stinkers, whom you have met, are getting old enough to want to

Re: Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Chuck Guzis via cctalk
On 2/19/19 2:02 PM, Fred Cisin via cctalk wrote: > Ability to read MFM data with FM headers (RX50) It's not that simple. There's the matter of "DEC MFM" which encodes a few bit patterns differently to avoid collision with FM headers. --Chuck

Ultimate FDC? (Was: IBM 6360 - Filesystem(ish) info?

2019-02-19 Thread Fred Cisin via cctalk
I'm planning on a USB controller, but I've seen ISA projects that are also microcontroller based so I think it wouldn't be awfully difficult to replace the USB data pipe with an ISA one. On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, Ali via cctalk wrote: Well just because you don't have enough to do please plan on an