Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-18 Thread Matt
I'll reply way back here but forward reference where appropriate. On 4/14/07, Randall Owen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > One topic that seemed to come up in a lot during the recent CellML Workshop in > Auckland was model validation, curation, and composition. This caused me to > think about a coup

Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-18 Thread Matt
I'll reply way back here but forward reference where appropriate. On 4/14/07, Randall Owen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > One topic that seemed to come up in a lot during the recent CellML Workshop in > Auckland was model validation, curation, and composition. This caused me to > think about a coup

Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-16 Thread David Nickerson
> The following is rather speculative - perhaps there is a way to do this > already that I'm unaware of. I'm just fishing for comments. always a good thing to be doing :-) > If you have a model which contains only math, and say you want to use it > as a component. It has no parameters, and you ne

Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-16 Thread James Lawson
> As for re-usability, again, in my view, implies that you have some > CellML model that can be re-used :-) Following the ideas of my "best > practices" this would be a model which contains just math with no > parameter values or initial conditions embedded in it such that I can > take that mat

Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-15 Thread David Nickerson
Hi Randy, Just to keep the discussion in on place, I include my earlier reply... Randall Owen wrote: > One topic that seemed to come up in a lot during the recent CellML Workshop > in Auckland was model validation, curation, and composition. This caused me > to think about a couple of questions

Re: [cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-15 Thread James Lawson
Dear Randall, Perhaps you'd care to give us a short definition of these terms from the perspective of the software engineering and computing communities? I think it would be useful for us to have some base definitions with which to compare our concepts of these terms. I'm looking forward to read

[cellml-discussion] CellML Validation, Curation and Model Composition

2007-04-13 Thread Randall Owen
One topic that seemed to come up in a lot during the recent CellML Workshop in Auckland was model validation, curation, and composition. This caused me to think about a couple of questions about which I would really appreciate the CellML community's thoughts: 1. What does validation mean to the