[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-29 Thread Eric Petit
>> At a Ceph Day in Hillsboro someone, forgive me for not remembering >> who, spoke of running production on servers with 2GB RAM per OSD. He >> said that it was painful, required a lot of work, and would not >> recommend it. ymmv. > > Yeah, I wouldn't want to go below 4GB RAM. FWIW, I have

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-28 Thread Kai Börnert
If you want to go cheap and somewhat questionable, there are some asrock mainboards with a soldered in atom cpu, that support up to 32gb memory (officially only 8, but the controller does more) and have 2 sata directly + a free 16x pcie port, Those boards are usually less than 90€, not as

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-27 Thread Anthony D'Atri
Also, only one Ethernet port.  Worse yet they have *zero* HIPPI ports! Can you imagine!?Never used HIPPIAlmost nobody has ;)A 48-port gigabit managed switch is reasonably accessible to the homegamer, both in terms of availability and cost.USD249 from Netgear, interesting.Second-hand 10GbE switches

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-27 Thread Stuart Longland
On Sat, 26 Jun 2021 08:01:46 -0500 Mark Nelson wrote: > FWIW, you can lower both the osd_memory_target and tweak a couple of > other settings that will lower bluestore memory usage.  A 2GB target is > about the lowest you can reasonably set it to (and you'll likely hurt > performance due to

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-27 Thread Stuart Longland
On Sat, 26 Jun 2021 10:06:10 -0700 Anthony D'Atri wrote: > A handful of years back WD Labs did their “microserver” project, a > cluster of 504 drives with an onboard ARM CPU and 1GB of RAM, 8TB > HDDs I think. But yeah that most likely was Filestore. > > At a Ceph Day in Hillsboro someone,

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-26 Thread Anthony D'Atri
>> - Bluestore requires OSD hosts with 8GB+ of RAM With Filestore I found that in production I needed to raise vm.min_free_kbytes, though inheriting the terrible mistake of -n size=65536 didn’t help. A handful of years back WD Labs did their “microserver” project, a cluster of 504 drives with

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-26 Thread Mark Nelson
On 6/26/21 12:53 AM, Stuart Longland wrote: On Tue, 1 Jun 2021 12:24:12 -0700 Neha Ojha wrote: Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether we can consider deprecating FileStore in our next release,

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-26 Thread Alexander E. Patrakov
сб, 26 июн. 2021 г. в 10:54, Stuart Longland : > > On Tue, 1 Jun 2021 12:24:12 -0700 > Neha Ojha wrote: > > > Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used > > objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether > > we can consider deprecating FileStore in our

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-26 Thread Stuart Longland
On Tue, 1 Jun 2021 12:24:12 -0700 Neha Ojha wrote: > Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used > objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether > we can consider deprecating FileStore in our next release, Quincy and > remove it in the R release. There

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-03 Thread Neha Ojha
On Thu, Jun 3, 2021 at 2:34 AM Ansgar Jazdzewski wrote: > > Hi folks, > > I'm fine with dropping Filestore in the R release! > Only one thing to add is: please add a warning to all versions we can upgrade > from to the R release son not only Quincy but also pacific! Sure! - Neha > > Thanks, >

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-03 Thread Willem Jan Withagen
On 2-6-2021 21:56, Neha Ojha wrote: On Wed, Jun 2, 2021 at 12:31 PM Willem Jan Withagen wrote: On 1-6-2021 21:24, Neha Ojha wrote: Hello everyone, Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether we can

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-03 Thread Ansgar Jazdzewski
Hi folks, I'm fine with dropping Filestore in the R release! Only one thing to add is: please add a warning to all versions we can upgrade from to the R release son not only Quincy but also pacific! Thanks, Ansgar Neha Ojha schrieb am Di., 1. Juni 2021, 21:24: > Hello everyone, > > Given that

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-02 Thread Willem Jan Withagen
On 1-6-2021 21:24, Neha Ojha wrote: Hello everyone, Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether we can consider deprecating FileStore in our next release, Quincy and remove it in the R release. There is

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-02 Thread Neha Ojha
On Wed, Jun 2, 2021 at 12:31 PM Willem Jan Withagen wrote: > > On 1-6-2021 21:24, Neha Ojha wrote: > > Hello everyone, > > > > Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used > > objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether > > we can consider deprecating

[ceph-users] Re: Can we deprecate FileStore in Quincy?

2021-06-02 Thread Janne Johansson
Den tis 1 juni 2021 kl 21:24 skrev Neha Ojha : > Hello everyone, > > Given that BlueStore has been the default and more widely used > objectstore since quite some time, we would like to understand whether > we can consider deprecating FileStore in our next release, Quincy and > remove it in the R