Re: [ChurchillChat] Another Churchill movie in the works

2016-09-15 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
Phone > On Sep 16, 2016, at 2:16 AM, Jon Lellenberg <jonlellenb...@gmail.com> wrote: > > I am hoping it will be based closely on John Kukacs' book Five Days in May, > 1940. But I am also wondering about the choice of Gary Oldman as Churchill. > >> On Thu, Sep 15, 20

Re: [ChurchillChat] USA TV Broadcast of Churchill's Secret

2016-09-15 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
"Overwrought". Amazing vilification of those who have some sense that 'historical fiction' has a real responsibility to comport itself somewhat close to the factual base. Unfortunately this production does a significant disservice to the current younger generation. Maybe a professor who is

Re: [ChurchillChat] USA TV Broadcast of Churchill's Secret

2016-09-15 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
David, While indeed the events of the 1953 stroke were "deep-sixed" at the time as anyone who might check with the papers at the National Archives, Kew, as I have done, could do. It has not been a secret since Lord Moran's book of now 50 years ago on his caring for WSC at this time. Also Lord

Re: [ChurchillChat] Another Churchill movie in the works

2016-09-15 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
This has great potential. I hope they get it right. Who will be their historical advisors? Do they have one or two already? I had heard a rumor that Lord David Owen is in the midst of a book on this period of history. He maybe. Roll on the script and cameras. John H. Mather MD FACPE Sent from

Re: [ChurchillChat] USA TV Broadcast of Churchill's Secret

2016-09-14 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
No no no. Randolph Churchill was Lord Brain in disguise and Lord Moran forgot his "Ps" & "Qs" with his hidden stethoscope while Anthony Eden was only there in spirit as he was recovery in Boston from serious repeat gallbladder surgery and OMG only one Amazon nurse to lift WSC to prevent

Re: [ChurchillChat] USA TV Broadcast of Churchill's Secret

2016-09-13 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
While I can appreciate a genuine piece of fiction is fiction. Yet when the fiction significantly "garbles" if not specifically "changes" the story line to comply with a preconceived notion of history rather than a reasonable devotion to accuracy then the criticism heaped upon it is most

Re: [ChurchillChat] USA TV Broadcast of Churchill's Secret

2016-09-13 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
Bravo Cita, Thank you for illuminating a further demonstration in this dastardly drama's gross liberties taken with history and the portrayal of the various personalities. This drama should be accepted as best a romp through one author's imagination rather than any serious attempt to ensure

Re: [ChurchillChat] 'Churchill's Secret': On PBS' 'Masterpiece'

2016-09-07 Thread 'John Mather' via ChurchillChat
See also reviews on Amazon in the UK and USA of the DVD sold through Amazon. Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 6, 2016, at 11:42 PM, Frank Sample <piper...@att.net> wrote: > > JOHN, THE ISSUE OF THE FINEST HOUR THAT YOU REFERRED TO IS THE SPRING, 2016, > PP 49-50. > > &