Re: [cisco-voip] [External] Re: ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Gentoo
Just fyi VG20x XM end of sale date is April 29, 2022. Replacement product is VG400 series at a higher price if you just want FXS ports. ATA-191 are an option, but the CUCM version doesn’t support power denial. > On Jan 25, 2022, at 14:43, Adam Pawlowski wrote: > > Sort of a derail, but

Re: [cisco-voip] [External] Re: ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Adam Pawlowski
Sort of a derail, but years ago we tested grandstream and audiocodes devices to replace the ATA-186. We weren't on 11.5 then and ultimately didn't implement either. Devices that provision as "basic" SIP devices in the UCM haven't been any trouble for basic features. Both devices worked for

Re: [cisco-voip] [External] Re: ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Lelio Fulgenzi
Yeah, this is definitely something to consider. We think we can do something cheaper, until it comes to adding another row to the maintenance schedule. It's hard in higher ed. We take it as a challenge. But we're never given the resources to maintain the secondary solution. I'd not consider

Re: [cisco-voip] [External] Re: ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Hunter Fuller via cisco-voip
Lelio, When we were considering this, we were going to have to come up with some other solution for centralized config. Almost any endpoint will do centralized config, just not from callmanager. We are capable of maintaining two systems but we did decide it wasn't worth it. I could definitely

Re: [cisco-voip] ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Scott Voll
we moved to vg204's to replace the ata's a long time ago. Scott On Tue, Jan 25, 2022 at 6:49 AM Lelio Fulgenzi wrote: > What’s the advantage of third party ATAs over Cisco branded? > > As far as I know, you’d be stuck with a third party SIP device which has > little centralized configuration

Re: [cisco-voip] ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Lelio Fulgenzi
What’s the advantage of third party ATAs over Cisco branded? As far as I know, you’d be stuck with a third party SIP device which has little centralized configuration options. Centralized upgrades and true failover are top of my list. Oh, and I’m not a pro, but from what I understand, they

[cisco-voip] ATA Devices

2022-01-25 Thread Lisa Notarianni
Anyone using Call Manager 11.5 or greater and successfully using a non-Cisco ATA device? We need to upgrade several 186s and looking at options. Thanks in advance... Lisa Notarianni University of Scranton Telecommunications Engineer Infrastructure Services 800 Linden St. Scranton PA 18510