Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-09 Thread Joe Lucia
After Chris Barr forwarded my message from NGC4LIB, I signed onto this list so I could see any replies. A bit of response latency, then, but I do want to react to what Carl Grant wrote. He made some very pertinent points and I think he's right on many points. To some degree, we are coming at

Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-09 Thread Carl Grant
For some more background/ideas that might be useful in this conversation, just in case you haven't seen it, I highly recommend reading: www.ithaka.org/strategic-services/oss/oss-organization-for-open- source-software-study I found this a fascinating paper and while it's over a year old now and

Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-09 Thread Roy Tennant
I agree with Jonathan's points below, and would suggest that a robust enough WorldCat API should be sufficient to allow any library that has the desire and the capacity to integrate everything available there with whatever else they wish. Roy On 11/9/07 9:42 AM, Jonathan Rochkind [EMAIL

Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-09 Thread K.G. Schneider
On 11/9/07 11:24 AM, Joseph Lucia [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: At the recent OCLC Members Council meeting there was some strong support voiced from the floor during OCLC management's general presentation for such an API, but it is not clear where OCLC stands on the matter. The answers from

Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-08 Thread Carl Grant
Alexander: I don't think you're dreaming at all. Sounds like the same vision I know several OSS service firms are trying to pursue. Not to be self serving here (really, anyone who knows me will tell you that's not my style!), but in the spirit of making sure you are aware, I'll note the

Re: [CODE4LIB] [Fwd: [NGC4LIB] A Thought Experiment]

2007-11-08 Thread Alexander Johannesen
Hiya, On Nov 9, 2007 7:42 AM, Carl Grant [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm seeking some help understanding here. From my perspective (again, that of a long time vendor of commercial software having recently moved to commercial service for OSS software) this is exactly what a number of us