Re: Homebrew Open Phone

2007-10-28 Thread Robin Paulson
On 22/10/2007, Ian Darwin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Doug Sutherland wrote:
  Compulab does have, and has always had, very interesting
  embedded boards. But before you get excited about this one

 The quantity 1 prices are 2.5x the listed prices which are for quantity
 1000. Add in a GPS, GSM (not included in base), enough memory to be
 usable, and you'll be paying about US$600 for it. Plus $100 for shipping
 to North America.

 So unless somebody has the cash to buy 500 or 1000 of these, it's not
 going to be a DIY project anytime soon.

does anyone know the word on openness of their hardware? i.e. are the
modules they supply in binary form, or as code? the hardware looks
fantastic and i've spent a while studying the specs, but if there's no
open code, i'll stick with openmoko/neo1973

if they were open, i'm sure - having seen the interest for this
project - we could come up with some sort of collective agreement for
bulk-purchasing the hardware. sometime in the past i've seen a website
that organises this sort of thing for buying TVs and music systems on
the cheap. anyone?

___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Homebrew Open Phone

2007-10-28 Thread andy selby
   Compulab does have, and has always had, very interesting
   embedded boards.

 does anyone know the word on openness of their hardware?

If you want open hardware, Balloon boards at http://balloonboard.org/
seem the most likely candidate, buy enough and you can specify your
own components http://balloonboard.org/hardware/buildoptions.html
Buy them from http://balloonboard.org/balloonwiki/BalloonzCompany

___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: Homebrew Open Phone

2007-10-28 Thread Doug Sutherland
Open hardware means availability of schematics and gerbers,
not source code, and this is not open hardware. Driver code 
is still in the software realm. For compulab's PXA270 boards, 
this is their listed OS support:

http://www.compulab.co.il/x270em/html/x270-em-os-support.htm

Since they list linux support presumably there is source but I
would check to make sure before buying. 

For harware details, products like this will usually include enough 
documentation of the hardware to do any kind of interfacing you 
need, but it's not open hardware unless they provide the full 
schematics and gerber files to produce pcb boards.

Doug Sutherland
Proficio Research
http://www.proficio.ca/


Regarding CompuLab hardware
 does anyone know the word on openness of their hardware? i.e. are the
 modules they supply in binary form, or as code? the hardware looks
 fantastic and i've spent a while studying the specs, but if there's no
 open code, i'll stick with openmoko/neo1973



___
OpenMoko community mailing list
community@lists.openmoko.org
http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community


Re: community@lists.openmoko.org

2007-10-28 Thread Flyin_bbb8
first: this is the community and not the freakin store

second: and about allowing other customers screaming at you the employees
here don't go on deletin posts 'n s*** for 1 customer because this is about
being open and it's community we work together we don't just buy, if u don't
want to work as a team with us then why would you even subscribe in
community? you must be stupid

third: about the deadlines u talkin about that's on the website, first off
that's the wiki, where any registered users (mostly the community) can edit
the information on it, plus who told you that those were deadlines? those
are only ESTIMATES

fourth: stop talkin about your business rules 'n business this 'n that, this
project is not just about money, it's about open source and teamwork, i'm
sure you have no idea what that, but it's ok, now you can go 'n unsubscribe
if u want, no ones stoppin you or stoppin me from saying this to you you
know why? cause THIS IS COMMUNITY

On 10/26/07, andutt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 Hello Mark

 I agree with you, i feel the problem with this project is the mix of
 commersial and hardware relates issues/questions that dont exist in other
 communites that often just are software related. In thoose projects the
 community is happy to get new eager users/developers/documenters/people who
 spread the word. I have always received initial respect, good behaviors from
 the persons in charge and people that have moderated the channels.

 The post you react on is really ugly, its just be glad or shutup and get
 the f*** out of here.

 Thats not good behavior, its not good for future buyers of the hardware,
 not good advertising for OpenMoko, people who reads it wont ask questions,
 maybe not be interested in contributing either.

 Qtopia has announsed to embrace the Neo device and have released the
 software under GPL which can have a very bad inpact on OpenMoko if the
 community gets a negative label printed on the forhead.

 Hopefully that wont happen and the project will continue with positive
 power!!!

 /Andreas






 On 10/26/07, Mark [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
  AVee [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  On Fri Oct 26 00:40:21 CEST 2007 AVee wrote:
  Did you buy a GTA02? No? Well, in that case, your not a customer, so
  quit
  bitching about 'customer service'. You are getting a peek into the
  development proccess at FIC, that not something you usually get with
  other
  companies and you surely can't claim some sort of right to be informed
  about
  this.
  If you can't handle it, unsubscribe from the community list and wait
  for the
  announcement you telling you the thing is available, *like you would
  with any
  other product*. Or be happy with whatever information you may get,
  realizing
  it's all extra.
  
  AVee
 
  Here's the deal: I'm already a customer in the same way that I'm the
  customer of a store the instant I pass the threshold. My experience in
  the store determines whether and how much money I spend in the store.
  If the employees ignore me (repeatedly) when I ask them a direct
  question, and allow other customers to scream and yell at me for
  simply asking a question, then I certainly will immediately exit the
  building and spend my money elsewhere. I also will tell everybody I
  know about my experience to prevent them going through the same thing.
 
  Whether you like it or not, OpenMoko will never get off the ground
  without the Neo1973, and the Neo1973 will never get off the ground
  without early adopters like me to buy it and spread the word. This is
  a business venture, not a pet project.
 
  On the other hand, if everything that prospective buyers hear is
  negative, that doesn't offer much hope for the future of this project.
 
  Question: Who is it wiser to treat well, someone whose money you
  already have, or someone whose money you need?
 
  Anybody here ever hear of the Agenda VR3? Probably very few. History
  is littered with multitudes of great ideas and great vaporware that
  never made it to mainstream because those behind it either didn't
  understand or thought they could get away with ignoring the rules of
  business.
 
  The first rule of business is not to alienate potential customers.
 
  Another of the biggest rules of business (and strongly associated with
  the first rule) is that when you know you aren't going to make a
  deadline (that you have plastered in multiple places all over your Web
  site), *before* the deadline passes you let people know what's going
  on. Making a single vague reference that buyers may or may not find is
  not sufficient.
 
  It's up to you: do the right thing, or go the way of the Agenda VR3.
  But if it's the latter, you can't say you haven't been warned.
 
  ___
  OpenMoko community mailing list
  community@lists.openmoko.org
  http://lists.openmoko.org/mailman/listinfo/community
 


 ___
 OpenMoko community mailing list