Re: [Community-Discuss] AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread Mark Tinka
I'm not sure having a meeting-specific mailing list helps here, because it assumes that attendees will always register. Brokers (and in particular, brokers who spam) can't be guaranteed to register, or more specifically, follow the rules. They could just show up as regular hotel guests, not

Re: [Community-Discuss] Fwd: AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread Mark Tinka
Totally agreed, which is why I feel that empowering the membership with enough knowledge to handle themselves well when approached by these brokers is the best solution all around. Ultimately, the final decision rests in the hands of those approaching, and those being approached. So let's equip

Re: [Community-Discuss] Fwd: AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread JORDI PALET MARTINEZ via Community-Discuss
Well … the so-called “Benjamin” broke *several times* the code of conduct: https://afrinic.net/code So should be ban from the meeting (and the lists) and not only Benjamin, but also the real person behind him. I’ve asked the staff/board to verify the information about who is behind

Re: [Community-Discuss] Fwd: AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread Andrew Alston
I would have a major problem with control over who attends the meetings. To be frank – meetings are about the community, and if we start deciding who can and who can’t attend the meetings – beyond the scope of a code of conduct – it’s a dangerous and slippery slope from there. I mean – I

Re: [Community-Discuss] Fwd: AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread Mark Tinka
Thanks, Andrew. Makes sense to me, but only if both the brokers and the interested RIR members abide by these rules. What I see more likely happening is either side finds this opt-in/out ineffective. If we somehow block the spamming and can control who attends the meetings, they'll just sidebar

Re: [Community-Discuss] Fwd: AFRINIC-31 Meeting

2019-11-17 Thread Andrew Alston
Personally I have another take on this - I do not agree with spam - or harvesting emails - period - so will start there. I do however think that it may be worth considering an opt in/opt out list for attendees of AfriNIC meetings where people who wish to promote services or give general