[computer-go] Strange Ko

2009-01-09 Thread Mark Boon
The attached game played on CGOS was awarded a win for white due to an illegal move. Black tried to play J3, which according to the game- record is a ko. Nothing could be further from the truth... Rather shocking really. What happened here? Mark 684276.sgf Description: Binary data

Re: [computer-go] Strange Ko

2009-01-09 Thread Jason House
Look at the board position at move 77 (black C9). The move of Black J3 is both a violation of positional superko (used by CGOS) and the more lax situational super ko. On Fri, Jan 9, 2009 at 12:40 PM, Mark Boon tesujisoftw...@gmail.com wrote: The attached game played on CGOS was awarded a win

Re: [computer-go] Strange Ko

2009-01-09 Thread unic (Ola Mikael Hansson)
If black plays J3, we would have the same board position as after move 77, thus violating superko. /Ola Mikael Hansson On Fri, Jan 9, 2009 at 6:40 PM, Mark Boon tesujisoftw...@gmail.com wrote: The attached game played on CGOS was awarded a win for white due to an illegal move. Black tried to

Re: [computer-go] Strange Ko

2009-01-09 Thread RĂ©mi Coulom
Mark Boon wrote: The attached game played on CGOS was awarded a win for white due to an illegal move. Black tried to play J3, which according to the game-record is a ko. Nothing could be further from the truth... Rather shocking really. What happened here? Mark It is a superko. Note that