[CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread t.piwowar
On Jun 1, 2009, at 6:15 PM, Rev. Stewart Marshall wrote: Yeah but Kryptonite will render them useless. After a particularly difficult caller on Science Friday the host remarked about Belief Silos -- clusters of unrelated beliefs that for some reason tend to be found together. I've been

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread Jeff Wright
...goes with magical thinking about free markets goes with ... Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. *pt* Tom, It only looks like magic if you don't understand it. [Waits for cranky, bilious rant filled with capitalist boogeymen, free market strawmen,

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread t.piwowar
On Jun 1, 2009, at 7:38 PM, Jeff Wright wrote: *pt* Tom, It only looks like magic if you don't understand it. Economics was one of my major fields in grad school. It was a top school -- one of our faculty won the Nobel Prize in Economics and was Carter's Economics advisor. I then spent

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Well Tom you know the real world definition of a PhD don't you? Stewart At 07:01 PM 6/1/2009, you wrote: On Jun 1, 2009, at 7:38 PM, Jeff Wright wrote: *pt* Tom, It only looks like magic if you don't understand it. Economics was one of my major fields in grad school. It was a top

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread Jeff Wright
Economics was one of my major fields in grad school. It was a top school -- one of our faculty won the Nobel Prize in Economics and was Carter's Economics advisor. I then spent a decade doing forecasting and analytical work. So that would not apply to me. Ah, appeals to authority. I left

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread t.piwowar
On Jun 1, 2009, at 8:13 PM, Rev. Stewart Marshall wrote: Well Tom you know the real world definition of a PhD don't you? I know what the bitterly ignorant like to call it. Di I care? * ** List info, subscription

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread t.piwowar
On Jun 1, 2009, at 7:38 PM, Jeff Wright wrote: *pt* Tom, It only looks like magic if you don't understand it. Paul Krugman offers a great explaination today... http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/01/opinion/01krugman.html

Re: [CGUYS] Belief Silos [Was: When I think know...]

2009-06-01 Thread t.piwowar
On Jun 1, 2009, at 8:57 PM, Jeff Wright wrote: I'm sure he does a fantastic job on your confirmation bias. He stopped being an economist long ago. You constantly reject insightful analysis by knowledgeable people in favor of magical thinking. That is your belief silo. Q.E.D.