Re: Proposed dorm speech code at the University of Alabama

2003-06-19 Thread Volokh, Eugene
Two questions: (1) Say a city bans all billboards with offensive signs, if the billboards are visible from a private residence; and also bans all tenants, in privately owned housing (including private university housing) as well as publicly owned housing, from displaying

Re: Proposed dorm speech code at the University of Alabama

2003-06-19 Thread Sisk, Gregory C.
The further expression is located (physically) from the interior and immediate precincipts of a person's home, the lesser the strength that should be accorded to the privacy/emotional-solace concerns of the resident. Similarly, if the expression is located in open or public areas, even if it could

Re: Proposed dorm speech code at the University of Alabama

2003-06-19 Thread Sisk, Gregory C.
Eugene's points are persuasively stated and just the kind of thoughtful arguments that I ordinarily would make (or at least aspire to making). Based upon slippery slope fears (cf. Eugene's recent article), I generally am most reluctant and most resistant to attempts to draw lines based upon