Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-26 Thread Neil Toda
Zhengyu Earlier creation of the environmental variable. http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ntoda/8042469/webrev-07/ The new webrev [07] places the new code in the function SetJvmEnvironment() === . JLI_Launch() . InitLauncher() . CreateExecutionEnvironment() . CheckJvmType() .

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-26 Thread Zhengyu Gu
Hi Neil, There is still an issue. Apparently, you can NOT free the buffer for the environment variable. 678 char * pbuf = (char*)JLI_MemAlloc(pbuflen); 679 JLI_Snprintf(pbuf, pbuflen, %s%d=%s, NMT_Env_Name, JLI_GetPid(), value); 680 retval =

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-26 Thread Neil Toda
You are right. I found this upon looking: https://www.securecoding.cert.org/confluence/display/seccode/POS34-C.+Do+not+call+putenv()+with+a+pointer+to+an+automatic+variable+as+the+argument We moved to malloc since the launcher doesn't know about the value being passed with the native memory

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-26 Thread Zhengyu Gu
The possible values are: off, summary and detail Thanks, -Zhengyu On 6/26/2014 3:58 PM, Neil Toda wrote: You are right. I found this upon looking:

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-25 Thread Neil Toda
Sorry. One more webrev .. 06 http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ntoda/8042469/webrev-06/ Kumar's nit was correct and in fact index was old and should have been removed allowing .contains member to be used instead of .indexOf. So cleaned up a bit more as can be seen below. Other of Kumar's nits

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-25 Thread Zhengyu Gu
Hi Neil, I tried out this patch with my hotspot, it does not work. The reason is that, the environment variable is setup too late, it has to be set before it launches JavaVM (before calling LoadJavaVM()) method. Thanks, -Zhengyu On 6/25/2014 1:58 PM, Neil Toda wrote: Sorry. One more

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-25 Thread Kumar Srinivasan
Hi Zhengyu, You are right then this needs to happen before LoadJavaVM, I think that is where it was initially, but I had Neil move it to ParseArguments where all the arguments are parsed. Also it is probably best that you push this changeset when it is complete, into hotspot-dev, along

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-24 Thread Kumar Srinivasan
Neil, Some nits: TestSpecialArgs.java: extra space 105 for ( String line : tr.testOutput) { This is very C'ish, I suggest. -106 int index; -107 if ((index = line.indexOf(envVarPidString)) = 0) { +106 int index =

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-23 Thread Neil Toda
I've spun a new webrev based on the comments for webrev-03: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ntoda/8042469/webrev-04/ Changes are: 1) java.c a) add free(envName) line 1063 b) change from malloc() to JLI_MemAlloc() @ lines 1048 and 1056 Thanks -neil On 6/20/2014 4:45 PM,

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-20 Thread Zhengyu Gu
Neil, Thanks for quick implementation. java.c: Did not check return values of malloc(), I wonder if source code analyzers will complain. -Zhengyu On 6/19/2014 8:29 PM, Neil Toda wrote: Launcher support for modified Native Memory Tracking mechanism in JVM in JDK9. Webrev :

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-20 Thread Joe Darcy
Memory allocation in the launcher should use one of the JLI_MemAlloc wrappers, if possible. -Joe On 06/20/2014 09:50 AM, Neil Toda wrote: They should complain. Thanks Zhengyu. I'll make sure these are non-null. -neil On 6/20/2014 5:01 AM, Zhengyu Gu wrote: Neil, Thanks for quick

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-20 Thread Neil Toda
Thanks Joe. It would have checked for NULL for me. I'll use the JLI wrapper. -neil On 6/20/2014 4:04 PM, Joe Darcy wrote: Memory allocation in the launcher should use one of the JLI_MemAlloc wrappers, if possible. -Joe On 06/20/2014 09:50 AM, Neil Toda wrote: They should complain.

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-20 Thread Kumar Srinivasan
Neil, Generally looks good, yes JLI_* functions must be used, I missed that one. Are you going to post another iteration ? Kumar On 6/20/2014 4:27 PM, Neil Toda wrote: Thanks Joe. It would have checked for NULL for me. I'll use the JLI wrapper. -neil On 6/20/2014 4:04 PM, Joe Darcy wrote:

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-20 Thread Neil Toda
Thanks Kumar for your other finds. I'll spin another webrev this evening and post it with the fixes to address everyone's points. Thanks. -neil On 6/20/2014 4:45 PM, Kumar Srinivasan wrote: Neil, Generally looks good, yes JLI_* functions must be used, I missed that one. Are you going

Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-19 Thread Neil Toda
Launcher support for modified Native Memory Tracking mechanism in JVM in JDK9. Webrev : http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ntoda/8042469/webrev-03/ bug : https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8042469 CCC : http://ccc.us.oracle.com/8042469 Thanks. -neil

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-19 Thread Vitaly Davidovich
Hi Neil, 1054 envName = malloc(pbuflen); envName is never freed looks like. Probably not a big deal since this runs only if launcher is traced, but thought I'd mention it. Sent from my phone On Jun 19, 2014 8:30 PM, Neil Toda neil.t...@oracle.com wrote: Launcher support

Re: Ready for Review : 8042469 : Launcher changes for native memory tracking scalability enhancement

2014-06-19 Thread Neil Toda
Thanks Vitaly. Best to cleanup. I'll make that change. -neil On 6/19/2014 5:39 PM, Vitaly Davidovich wrote: Hi Neil, 1054 envName = malloc(pbuflen); envName is never freed looks like. Probably not a big deal since this runs only if launcher is traced, but thought