Re: Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-07-04 Thread Jaroslav Rakhmatoullin
If a user wants to (makes the mistake of) let others delete their files, it's not your job to teach them otherwise. Compare to real life; someone leaves a bike on the street unlocked and someone else steals it. Does it make sense to file a complaint to the police department about not educating

Re: Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-07-04 Thread Ben Lentz
On Thu, Jul 4, 2013 at 8:12 AM, Jaroslav Rakhmatoullin jazzos...@gmail.com wrote: If a user wants to (makes the mistake of) let others delete their files, it's not your job to teach them otherwise. Compare to real life; someone leaves a bike on the street unlocked and someone else steals it.

Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-06-27 Thread Ben Lentz
I suspect I may get laughed off the list... but would you folks ever consider restricting the use of chmod such that world-writable files are reserved for 1) /tmp-style permissions (1777) or 2) reserved for root-only users? Despite training (berating?) users, it seems the default reaction to oh

Re: Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-06-27 Thread Ben Lentz
And the kernel devs would never allow it. You may still want to patch your local systems, either chmod or the kernel. However, this will not be accepted upstream. Although it might not be apparent, do I understand this. It would be trivial to write a perl program to replace chmod and permit

Re: Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-06-27 Thread Joseph D. Wagner
On 06/27/2013 1:03 pm, Ben Lentz wrote: And the kernel devs would never allow it. You may still want to patch your local systems, either chmod or the kernel. However, this will not be accepted upstream. My suggestion was merely meant to insight thought in the user attempting to set files

Re: Feature Request: disallow world-writable files in chmod

2013-06-27 Thread Bob Proulx
Ben Lentz wrote: I suspect I may get laughed off the list... but would you folks ever consider restricting the use of chmod such that world-writable files are reserved for 1) /tmp-style permissions (1777) or 2) reserved for root-only users? Despite training (berating?) users, it seems the