Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread Christian-Emil Smith Ore
Dear all, It is consistent to say “indeed” both to what Martin wrote and what George wrote below. If we see CRM as an ontology or a (logical) theory, then a realization or serialization, if one prefer that term, in RDF is on the implementation level (or more formally it is a valid model for

Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread George Bruseker
Dear all, While I agree that it is the case that RDF is only one potential serialization of CRM, it is nevertheless a fact on the ground it is the most popular at the moment and a standard into which people invest real time and real money. It is, typically, where CRM becomes flesh. Since CRM

Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread Christian-Emil Smith Ore
​Indeed! Christian-Emil From: Crm-sig on behalf of Martin Doerr Sent: 28 February 2018 11:38 To: crm-sig@ics.forth.gr Subject: Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90 Dear All, I'd like to remind you that RDF-OWL is only a historical phenomenon in the history

Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear All, I'd like to remind you that RDF-OWL is only a historical phenomenon in the history of knowledge representation. The CRM needs to define semantics that cover E-R, TELOS, KL-One, KIF, OIL, DAML-OIL, DL, RDFS, XML, Jason, and whatever will come up. Therefore we define it in FOL. The

Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear Philip, Let me clarify here a fundamental principle of the CRM, which is not negotiable: Labels are mnemonics, and not semantics. There is no way by selecting a term to overcome the ambiguity of natural language. A CRM property is therefore defined semantically by the scope note and

Re: [Crm-sig] Domain and range of P90

2018-02-28 Thread Conal Tuohy
I have used rdf:value for this purpose. https://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-schema/#ch_value The CRM's origin was outside of the RDF space, and it is still considered to be something more abstract than any concrete expression in RDFS or OWL. This is why, I think, there remains a puzzling gap between RDF