Re: Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-22 Thread James A. Donald
-- Steven M. Bellovin wrote: That isn't supposed to be possible these days... (I regard it as more likely that they were doing traffic analysis and direction-finding than actually cracking the ciphers.) Ciphers cannot be cracked when used correctly. However, military cipher procedures

Re: Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-22 Thread Travis H.
On 9/20/06, Leichter, Jerry [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Newspaper reports have claimed that many troops were sent into the field with old equipment - including in particular 10+-year-old communications equipment. The Single Channel Ground and Airborne Radio System was designed in the 80's:

Re: Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-22 Thread Thomas
(I regard it as more likely that they were doing traffic analysis and direction-finding than actually cracking the ciphers.) IIUC, spread-spectrum communication is not much stronger than the background noise, and thus the traffic analysis is not that easy either. We can just speculate

Re: Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-21 Thread Leichter, Jerry
| http://www.newsday.com/news/printedition/stories/ny-wocode184896831sep18,0,7091966,print.story | | That isn't supposed to be possible these days... (I regard it as more | likely that they were doing traffic analysis and direction-finding than | actually cracking the ciphers.) Newspaper

Re: Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-21 Thread Alexander Klimov
On Wed, 20 Sep 2006, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: http://www.newsday.com/news/printedition/stories/ny-wocode184896831sep18,0,7091966,print.story That isn't supposed to be possible these days... It is not clear that with modern technology interception is impossible, at least during Second Gulf War

Did Hezbollah use SIGINT against Israel?

2006-09-20 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
http://www.newsday.com/news/printedition/stories/ny-wocode184896831sep18,0,7091966,print.story That isn't supposed to be possible these days... (I regard it as more likely that they were doing traffic analysis and direction-finding than actually cracking the ciphers.) --Steven