stego in the wild: bomb-making CDs

2003-12-28 Thread John Denker
] Thursday 25 December 2003, 17:13 Makka Time, 14:13 GMT
]
] Saudis swoop on DIY bomb guide
] 
] Authorities in the kingdom have arrested five people after
] raiding computer shops selling compact disks containing
] hidden bomb-making instructions, a local newspaper reported
] on Thursday.
] 
] Police were questioning four owners of computer shops in the
] southern Jazan region and a fifth person believed to have
] supplied the CDs to the shops, Al-Watan newspaper said.
] 
] Officials were not immediately available for comment.
] 
] The daily said some of the shop owners might not have known
] about the bomb-making tutorial files hidden on the CDs. Only
] someone with technical knowledge would be able to find the
] files.

That was quoted from:
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/C8061E36-E4E5-4EB5-A103-19DCF838E835.htm
and the same story, almost verbatim, was carried by Reuters.

Comments:
 1) This is not entirely unprecedented.  Al Qaeda for years has
been hiding recruitment and training footage in the middle
of otherwise-innocuous video tape cassettes.  
 2) OTOH using a commercial distribution channel bespeaks a 
certain boldness ... somebody is thinking big.  
 3) Also: as a rule, anything you do with computers generates 
more headlines than doing the same thing with lower-tech methods.
This is significant to terrorists, who are always looking for
headlines.  Conversely it is significant to us, who have much
to lose when our not-so-fearless leaders over-react.
 4) One wonders how many CDs were distributed before the operation
was terminated.
 5) I wonder how the authorities found out about it.
 6) The article speaks of technical skill ... I wonder how 
much technical skill was required.  Probably not much.
 7) Did it rely entirely on security-by-obscurity, or was there 
crypto involved also?
(The latter is possible;  whatever leak told the authorities
where to look could also have told them the passphrase...
but the article didn't mention crypto.)

I suspect there is a lot more to this story..

-
The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending unsubscribe cryptography to [EMAIL PROTECTED]


Re: stego in the wild: bomb-making CDs

2003-12-28 Thread Peter Gutmann
John Denker [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

] Thursday 25 December 2003, 17:13 Makka Time, 14:13 GMT
]
] Saudis swoop on DIY bomb guide

[...]

I suspect there is a lot more to this story..

The story could apply to any one of hundreds (thousands?) of hacker/warez CDs
available off-the-shelf in the US.  Heck, it could apply to the Encyclopedia 
Britannica CD edition.  So I'd pick:

 3) Also: as a rule, anything you do with computers generates
   more headlines than doing the same thing with lower-tech methods.

because:

] Saudis swoop on DIY bomb guide

sounds a lot better than:

] Saudis swoop on Britannica vendors

Peter.

-
The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending unsubscribe cryptography to [EMAIL PROTECTED]