Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-13 Thread John D. Baker
On Thu, 13 Feb 2020, Jarom??r Dole?~Mek wrote: > Le jeu. 13 f??vr. 2020 ?? 17:28, John D. Baker > a ??crit : > > Instead of a blank screen, the display simply freezes in VGA text mode > > when nouveaufb0 attaches. See my latest addendum to kern/52440. > > I see the problem happens on G84 and

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-13 Thread Jaromír Doleček
Le jeu. 13 févr. 2020 à 17:28, John D. Baker a écrit : > > On Wed, 12 Feb 2020, Jaromír DoleÄ~Mek wrote: > > > I've just committed a fix for the MSI interrupt allocation for > > nouveau, can you try it on the system which had the trouble with blank > > console? > > Instead of a blank screen, the

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-13 Thread John D. Baker
On Wed, 12 Feb 2020, Jarom??r Dole?~Mek wrote: > I've just committed a fix for the MSI interrupt allocation for > nouveau, can you try it on the system which had the trouble with blank > console? Instead of a blank screen, the display simply freezes in VGA text mode when nouveaufb0 attaches.

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-12 Thread John D. Baker
On Wed, 12 Feb 2020, Jarom??r Dole?~Mek wrote: > I've just committed a fix for the MSI interrupt allocation for > nouveau, can you try it on the system which had the trouble with blank > console? > > It needs rev. 1.7 of >

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-12 Thread Jaromír Doleček
Le mer. 12 févr. 2020 à 03:38, John D. Baker a écrit : > I've checked this with plain GENERIC and one with the above file rolled > back. With plain generic, nouveau, intel, and radeon all work and have > MSI off. With the modified GENERIC, nouveau systems work (MSI off) and > intel and radeon

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-11 Thread John D. Baker
On Tue, 11 Feb 2020, Jarom??r Dole?~Mek wrote: > If it's something simple let's fix it and enable MSI unconditionally, > if it would be something difficult then it would be reasonable to add > some conditionals to enable MSI only for non-nouveau. At present, simply rolling back:

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-11 Thread John D. Baker
On Tue, 11 Feb 2020, Jarom??r Dole?~Mek wrote: > I've now got a nVidia card which triggers the problem on my rig x86 > system, will look into the nouveau-specific panic over next week or > so. I presume the problem you refer to is the panic after recent MSI re-enabling? What about the original

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-11 Thread John D. Baker
On Tue, 11 Feb 2020, Patrick Welche wrote: > Just BTW, I remember a nouveau system that was unhappy with EFI but > happy with legacy BIOS - different initialisation? worth a try? One machine at my disposal predates the existence of EFI. It is the only one that had no problem when MSI was first

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-11 Thread Patrick Welche
On Fri, Feb 07, 2020 at 04:22:19PM -0600, John D. Baker wrote: > I see that the MSI changes have been reverted. I have not yet updated > my sources and still have the MSI-enabled sources plus proposed nouveau > patch applied in my kernels. > > FWIW, quick tests with known-to-work radeon and

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-11 Thread Jaromír Doleček
Le ven. 7 févr. 2020 à 23:22, John D. Baker a écrit : > I see that the MSI changes have been reverted. I have not yet updated > my sources and still have the MSI-enabled sources plus proposed nouveau > patch applied in my kernels. > > FWIW, quick tests with known-to-work radeon and intel

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-07 Thread John D. Baker
I see that the MSI changes have been reverted. I have not yet updated my sources and still have the MSI-enabled sources plus proposed nouveau patch applied in my kernels. FWIW, quick tests with known-to-work radeon and intel graphics devices show that they are quite happy with MSI. It's only

Re: panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-06 Thread Jared McNeill
I'll try to have a look at it over the next few days. Unfortunately this is an x86 specific problem and I don't have one to test so it could take some time to work out. On Wed, 5 Feb 2020, John D. Baker wrote: Recently MSI was re-enabled for DRM devices generally and nouveau devices

panic after DRM & nouveau MSI changes

2020-02-05 Thread John D. Baker
Recently MSI was re-enabled for DRM devices generally and nouveau devices specifically. The resulting kernel panics attaching the framebuffer console on nouveau-equipped machines. See the two most recent addenda to PR kern/52440 for details. Thanks. -- |/"\ John D. Baker, KN5UKS