Re: tar and lzma

2008-05-04 Thread Yaakov (Cygwin Ports)
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 Eric Blake wrote: | automake's dist-lzma already functions if you install lzma (I know, | because I used it when creating m4 1.4.10b); automake uses 'tar | lzma' | rather than 'tar --lzma'. Furthermore, 'make distcheck' uses 'unlzma | tar'. Our

Re: tar and lzma

2008-05-04 Thread Charles Wilson
Yaakov (Cygwin Ports) wrote: Eric Blake wrote: | automake's dist-lzma already functions if you install lzma (I know, | because I used it when creating m4 1.4.10b); automake uses 'tar | lzma' | rather than 'tar --lzma'. Furthermore, 'make distcheck' uses 'unlzma | tar'. Our lzma-4.43-2 does

Re: tar and lzma

2008-02-29 Thread Charles Wilson
Eric Blake wrote: Although in this case, automake could (and probably should) add lzma as a dependency, since automake is not in Base either. Users who want automake already committed to more than the default. I added that dependency in 1.10.1-1 -- Chuck

tar and lzma

2008-02-28 Thread Eric Blake
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I'm about to upload tar 1.19.90, which adds the --lzma command-line option. Should I make tar depend on the lzma package? Arguments for: it already depends on gzip and bzip2. Also, there was talk on this list a while ago about switching to lzma,

Re: tar and lzma

2008-02-28 Thread Brian Dessent
Eric Blake wrote: Arguments for: it already depends on gzip and bzip2. Also, there was talk on this list a while ago about switching to lzma, instead of bzip2, for files installed via setup.exe, since it gives the best compression ratios to decompression speed tradeoff among all the popular

Re: tar and lzma

2008-02-28 Thread Eric Blake
, because I used it when creating m4 1.4.10b); automake uses 'tar | lzma' rather than 'tar --lzma'. | | I'm all for fighting bloat, but we're talking about 68KB extra to | download and ~150KB extra disk space, so I don't think it's too big of a | deal. At any rate, I'll do the upload now without

Re: tar and lzma

2008-02-28 Thread Brian Dessent
Eric Blake wrote: automake's dist-lzma already functions if you install lzma (I know, because I used it when creating m4 1.4.10b); automake uses 'tar | lzma' rather than 'tar --lzma'. Right; I meant having lzma (vicariously) in Base would also help users of automake. Brian

Re: tar and lzma

2008-02-28 Thread Eric Blake
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 According to Brian Dessent on 2/28/2008 9:32 PM: | Eric Blake wrote: | | automake's dist-lzma already functions if you install lzma (I know, | because I used it when creating m4 1.4.10b); automake uses 'tar | lzma' | rather than 'tar --lzma