Re: The CDR as a Cliological experiment

2002-11-30 Thread Tyler Durden
"(Tyler Durden, _please_ learn to trim your replies. Your "quote the entire thing" top posting is getting tiresome. I hear there are night school classes which teach Outlook Express or whichever braindead mailer you are using.)" Damn are you grumpy Tim May. Whaddya usin', carrier pigeon to down

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Eugen Leitl
On Sat, 30 Nov 2002, Morlock Elloi wrote: > > 1. large wifi networks start to hit scaling problems - they start to need > > routers and name services that are relatively expensive, and ip address Geographic routing completely eliminates need for expensive routing and admin traffic. Name services

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Tyler Durden
"its possible I am wrong and there is a wonderful distributed-computing method to solve these purely network routing problems, but it is news to me." I just don't see how a single WiFi cloud will be able to scale very far. All the WiFi users within "eyeshot" of each other are always going to con

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Morlock Elloi
> 1. large wifi networks start to hit scaling problems - they start to need > routers and name services that are relatively expensive, and ip address > ranges start to become a scarce resource. Not so. Self-organasing mesh networks appear to have some interesting properties. There is a number of o

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Dave Howe
Morlock Elloi wrote: > Not so. Self-organasing mesh networks appear to have some interesting > properties. There is a number of open solutions and at least one > startup I know about based on this. fascinating - I obviously have a lot of reading to do - thankyou :)

Re: The CDR as a Cliological experiment

2002-11-30 Thread Tyler Durden
"The vast majority of people are not interested in 'getting along' or 'live and let live', they are interested in creating an environment where the acceptable views and activities are limited (usually pretty severely). This problem will only become more clear as the differences in the potential

Re: The CDR as a Cliological experiment

2002-11-30 Thread Tim May
On Saturday, November 30, 2002, at 05:23 PM, Tyler Durden wrote: As far as I'm concerned, most strife boils down to the perceived economic interests of the concerned parties, and apparently ehtnic/religious/whatever differences are just a mask for these simpler problems. As a big for instance,

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Dave Howe
Eugen Leitl wrote: > On Sat, 30 Nov 2002, Morlock Elloi wrote: > >>> 1. large wifi networks start to hit scaling problems - they start >>> to need routers and name services that are relatively expensive, >>> and ip address > Geographic routing completely eliminates need for expensive routing > and

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Morlock Elloi
> > Geographic routing completely eliminates need for expensive routing > > and admin traffic. Name services? Who needs name services? Localhost > > is sufficient for a prefix to an address namepace. > without routing and name services, you have what amounts to a propriatory > NAT solution - no way

Re: The CDR as a Cliological experiment

2002-11-30 Thread Tim May
On Saturday, November 30, 2002, at 07:05 PM, Tyler Durden wrote: "(Tyler Durden, _please_ learn to trim your replies. Your "quote the entire thing" top posting is getting tiresome. I hear there are night school classes which teach Outlook Express or whichever braindead mailer you are using.)"

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Dave Howe
Jim Choate wrote: > On Sat, 30 Nov 2002, Dave Howe wrote: > The scaling problem is a valid one up to a point. The others are not. > The biggest problem is people trying to do distributed computing using > non-distributed os'es (eg *nix clones and Microsloth). not as such, no. the vast majority of "

Re: A couple of book questions...(one of them about Completeness)

2002-11-30 Thread Peter Fairbrother
Jim Choate wrote: > > With regard to completeness, I have Godel's paper ("On Formally > Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems", K. > Godel, ISBN 0-486-66980-7 (Dover), $7 US) and if somebody happens to know > the section where he defines completeness I'll be happy t

Re: CDR: Re: A couple of book questions...(one of them aboutCompleteness)

2002-11-30 Thread Jim Choate
On Sat, 30 Nov 2002, Peter Fairbrother wrote: > Jim Choate wrote: > > > > With regard to completeness, I have Godel's paper ("On Formally > > Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems", K. > > Godel, ISBN 0-486-66980-7 (Dover), $7 US) and if somebody happens to know >

Re: CDR: Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov.29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Jim Choate
On Sat, 30 Nov 2002, Dave Howe wrote: > > http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/11/21/yourtech.wifis/index.html > Its a nice idea, but unfortunately gets easily bitten by the usual > networking bugbears > 1. large wifi networks start to hit scaling problems - they start to need > routers and name services

Re: Anyone heard about the Berkeley college student?

2002-11-30 Thread Jim Choate
On Fri, 29 Nov 2002, Tyler Durden wrote: > Yeah, the paper originates from NYC, called Shi Chie Re Bau (in Pin Yin, I > believe). This translates (roughly) "World Journal". The article got thrown > out, otherwise I'd attempt a translation. > >On Fri, 29 Nov 2002, Tyler Durden wrote: > > > > > In

Re: CNN.com - WiFi activists on free Web crusade - Nov. 29, 2002 (fwd)

2002-11-30 Thread Dave Howe
> http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/11/21/yourtech.wifis/index.html Its a nice idea, but unfortunately gets easily bitten by the usual networking bugbears 1. large wifi networks start to hit scaling problems - they start to need routers and name services that are relatively expensive, and ip address ran