Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-18 Thread Adam Shostack
On Sun, Aug 18, 2002 at 01:46:09AM -0400, dmolnar wrote: | | | On Sat, 17 Aug 2002, John Kelsey wrote: | | Also, designing new crypto protocols, or analyzing old ones used in odd | ways, is mostly useful for companies that are offering some new service on | the net, or doing some wildly new

Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-17 Thread John Kelsey
At 12:57 PM 8/16/02 -0400, Perry E. Metzger wrote: ... I've seen very high rates of unemployment among people of all walks of life in New York of late -- I know a lot of lawyers, systems administrators, secretaries, advertising types, etc. who are out of work or have been underemployed for a

Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-17 Thread John Kelsey
At 04:21 AM 8/16/02 -0400, dmolnar wrote: ... Don't forget schedule pressure, the overhead of bringing in a contractor to do crypto protocol design, and the not-invented-here syndrome. I think all of these contribute to keeping protocol design in-house, regardless of the technical skill of the

Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-16 Thread dmolnar
On Fri, 16 Aug 2002, Adam Back wrote: failure to realise this issue or perhaps just not caring, or lack of financial incentives to care on the part of software developers. Microsoft is really good at this one. The number of times they re-used RC4 keys in different protocols is amazing!

Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-16 Thread Perry E. Metzger
Adam Back [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Are there any more definitive security industry stats? Are applied crypto people suffering higher rates of unemployment than general application programmers? (From my statistically too small sample of acquaintances it might appear so.) Hard to say.

Re: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-16 Thread Adam Shostack
Hey, this is off-topic for DRM-punks! ;) more seriously: I think the fundamental issue is that crypto doesn't really solve many business problems, and it may solve fewer security problems. See Bellovin's work on how many vulnerabilities would be blocked by strong crypto. The buying public can't

RE: employment market for applied cryptographers?

2002-08-16 Thread despot
Having devoted security personnel is a low priority at most companies. General engineers will be tasked with figuring out how to incorporate security and cryptography into products. I have visited many a company where I am talking to a room full of very sharp engineers, but there is a fundamental