Re: [Dailydave] CVSS is the worst compression algorithm ever

2019-01-08 Thread Konrads Smelkovs
The question is not whether it is a bad metric, but whether it is a useful one. As a lurker on the first.org mailing list for CVSSv3 SIG, I can assure you that there are a lot of discussions about edge cases etc. v3 is a meaningful improvement over v2. So far, CVSS has allowed industry broadly to

Re: [Dailydave] CVSS is the worst compression algorithm ever

2019-01-08 Thread Monroe, Bruce
Hi Dave, I participate on the CVSS SIG being ran out of FIRST that is working on improvements to CVSS. So do a number of people out of CERT CC, NIST, MITRE along with a good representation of industry. A number of us provided feedback on this paper. CVSS is for scoring the severity of a

Re: [Dailydave] CVSS is the worst compression algorithm ever

2019-01-08 Thread Nathaniel Ferguson
> They use a ton of big words in the paper to call CVSS out and give it a > shellacking. Like most of you, we have extensive use of CVSS in our > consulting practice and I've seen this stuff first hand. CVSS is of course > just a buggy compression algorithm for taking complex qualitative data

[Dailydave] CVSS is the worst compression algorithm ever

2019-01-08 Thread Dave Aitel
I wanted to take a few minutes and do a quick highlight of a paper from CMU-CERT which I think most people have missed out on: https://resources.sei.cmu.edu/asset_files/WhitePaper/2018_019_001_538372.pdf Towards Improving CVSS -