severity 300251 wishlist
tags 300251 + wontfix
thanks

Sorry but I think scilab needs patching for the following reasons:

1. xaw3d is a fork of Xaw6.1, not a replacement for Xaw7.
2. IF scilab needed a Xaw7 API it should link Xaw7, not Xaw3d which is not
   basically compatible with that. If not, who cares to link Xaw7
   instead of Xaw6 and so Xaw3d? If it is not required, WHY scilab
   does that kind of check?
3. Xaw3d maintainer is passed away in 2004 unfortunately, so I have
   no idea if someone will care to update the lib to be plain compatible
   with Xaw7. Note that I had no time to check how much Xaw7 is
   different from the previous edition and Xaw3d as well.
4. Changing soname without a specific API/ABI reason is silly and could
   possibly break programs which link the current solib. For sure it
   would require a questionable transition for a few programs in debian.

-- 
Francesco P. Lovergine


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to