For the record:

There is some online documentation for the 'fixed-upstream' tag here:

        http://www.debian.org/Bugs/Developer#tags

        fixed-upstream

        The bug has been fixed by the upstream maintainer, but not yet in the
        package (for whatever reason: perhaps it is too complicated to backport
        the change or too minor to be worth bothering).

It also shows a perhaps more appropriate tag:

        fixed-in-experimental

        The bug has been fixed in the package of the experimental distribution,
        but not yet in the unstable distribution.

I think there's probably a separate bug in this: that version vagueness
is possible, (mechanically possible), if a precise answer exists; as it did
in this instance.

"version vagueness" illustrated.  NOT VAGUE:

        #405609: nethogs: crashes when eth0 is not available 
        Package: nethogs (nethogs 0.6.0-1; fixed: nethogs 0.6.0-2); Severity: 
important;                Reported by: Cesar Martinez Izquierdo <[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]>
        Done: Bart Martens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>.

The second line "fixed: nethogs 0.6.0-2" is just what users need to know.

Compare bug #374824, (VAGUE):

        #374824: nethogs: 'ppp0' doesn't work. 
        Package: nethogs (nethogs 0.6.0-1); Reported by: "A. Costa" <[EMAIL 
PROTECTED]>;                Tags: fixed-upstream
        Done: Bart Martens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>.

The second line fails to mention which version fixed it.  Better it should say:

        Package: nethogs (nethogs 0.6.0-1; fixed: nethogs 0.6.0+cvs20070620-1); 
Reported by: "A. Costa" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; 


HTH...



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to