Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-09-21 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Guillem, > Checking for VERBOSE explicitly in the init scripts seems like an > anti-pattern to me. Indeed. However, I am unsure whether adding this tag would be very useful given how many (apparently) true-positives it would raise:

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-09-21 Thread Guillem Jover
On Wed, 2019-09-11 at 16:50:54 +, Dmitry Bogatov wrote: > [2019-09-08 21:26] "Chris Lamb" > > > unwanted and to be fixed. > > > > ... but, unless I'm missing something you can surely do that now > > almost trivially using codesearch.debian.net and certainly much > > quicker, independetly and

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-09-11 Thread Dmitry Bogatov
control: tags -1 -moreinfo [2019-09-08 21:26] "Chris Lamb" > > unwanted and to be fixed. > > ... but, unless I'm missing something you can surely do that now > almost trivially using codesearch.debian.net and certainly much > quicker, independetly and with less hassle than introducing two new

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-09-08 Thread Chris Lamb
tags 935607 + moreinfo retitle 935607 lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" / use of $VERBOSE (etc.) in init.d scripts thanks Hi Dmitry, > When we see, which of these styles is majority, we can proclaim other > unwanted and to be fixed. ... but, unless I'm missing something you can surely do that

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-08-28 Thread Dmitry Bogatov
control: tags -1 -moreinfo [2019-08-27 10:23] "Chris Lamb" > Hi Dmitry, > > > [ Should I tag '-moreinfo' on reply, or you prefer doing it yourself? ] > > Please. A wishlist bug with "moreinfo" means (at least for me) that it > is blocking on input from the reporter/requester and, if you

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-08-27 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Dmitry, > [ Should I tag '-moreinfo' on reply, or you prefer doing it yourself? ] Please. A wishlist bug with "moreinfo" means (at least for me) that it is blocking on input from the reporter/requester and, if you believe you have resolved all the outstanding queries, then it makes sense to

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-08-26 Thread Dmitry Bogatov
[ Should I tag '-moreinfo' on reply, or you prefer doing it yourself? ] [2019-08-24 14:44] "Chris Lamb" > > some init.d script print description of service they are starting with > > following line: > > > > log_daemon_msg "Starting X display manager" "xdm" > > or > >

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-08-24 Thread Chris Lamb
# marking as moreinfo simply for triage tags 935607 + moreinfo thanks Hi Dmitry, > some init.d script print description of service they are starting with > following line: > > log_daemon_msg "Starting X display manager" "xdm" > or > log_action_begin_msg "Starting $DESC" > > The

Bug#935607: lintian: classify "Starting $DESC" in init.d scripts

2019-08-24 Thread Dmitry Bogatov
Package: lintian Version: 2.17.0 Severity: wishlist (inspired by #658374) Dear Maintainer, some init.d script print description of service they are starting with following line: log_daemon_msg "Starting X display manager" "xdm" or log_action_begin_msg "Starting $DESC" The