Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-10-13 Thread Nicholas D Steeves
Hi Daniel and everyone reading this, Daniel writes: > I am addressing another case, the one you have not separated partitions > for /, /home and swap. > Len and Daniel, WRT swap, hibernation is useful when you need to preserve the state of applications that aren't aware of a desktop session

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-10-02 Thread Lennart Sorensen
On Mon, Sep 30, 2019 at 12:51:33PM -0400, Daniel wrote: > Dear Lennart, > > I hope that when one opens a "whishlist bug" at least there is a chance to > have a confrontation. > > The main point I want to address is when you do a "smart installation" it is > supposed to perform a clean

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-30 Thread Daniel
Dear Lennart, I hope that when one opens a "whishlist bug" at least there is a chance to have a confrontation. The main point I want to address is when you do a "smart installation" it is supposed to perform a clean installation hence the only folder that must to be untouched is "/home".

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-30 Thread Lennart Sorensen
On Sat, Sep 28, 2019 at 11:27:29PM -0400, Daniel wrote: > Hi Nicholas, > > thanks for your reply, I really appreciated your constructive approach. > > I use Debian since 2007 and I did a lot of installation, I personally use a > FrankenDebian (testing with pinning toward SID and Experimental)

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-28 Thread Daniel
Hi Nicholas, thanks for your reply, I really appreciated your constructive approach. I use Debian since 2007 and I did a lot of installation, I personally use a FrankenDebian (testing with pinning toward SID and Experimental) however when I install Debian on other machines I install

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-27 Thread Daniel
I am addressing another case, the one you have not separated partitions for /, /home and swap. As a matter of fact if the installer is able to recognize the home folder havingĀ  /home separated in another partition is not necessary anymore. The advantage respect having the /home separated,

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-27 Thread Nicholas D Steeves
Geert Stappers writes: > On Fri, Sep 27, 2019 at 05:19:06PM -0400, Daniel wrote: >> Holger Wansing wrote: >> > The debian-installer supports similar use case via the "separate >> > partition for /home" approach. >> to reinstall Debian on top of itself without overwriting the home partition. > >

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-27 Thread Geert Stappers
On Fri, Sep 27, 2019 at 05:19:06PM -0400, Daniel wrote: > Holger Wansing wrote: > > The debian-installer supports similar use case via the "separate > > partition for /home" approach. > to reinstall Debian on top of itself without overwriting the home partition. Yes, that is what Holger is

Bug#935931: Re: Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-27 Thread Daniel
Dear All, In this case I suggest hence to expand the use cases and to evaluate the feature to reinstall Debian on top of itself without overwriting the home partition. While it doesn't seem a complicated achievement, it brings instead a great advantage for the end user and improves greatly

Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-09-24 Thread Holger Wansing
Hi, Daniel wrote: > Package: debian-installer > Severity: wishlist > > Dear Maintainer, this is a feature request. > > Debian related distros like POP!_os and ElementaryOS, when the system is > installed in one partition: I mean inside "/", have the ability to recognize > the previous

Bug#935931: debian-installer: Reinstalling Debian on a current Debian installation without erasing or fomatting the home folder

2019-08-27 Thread Daniel
Package: debian-installer Severity: wishlist Dear Maintainer, this is a feature request. Debian related distros like POP!_os and ElementaryOS, when the system is installed in one partition: I mean inside "/", have the ability to recognize the previous installation and reinstalling the system