Bug#407119: emacs-snapshot: German dictionaries for ispell not works in emacs snapshot

2007-07-18 Thread Agustin Martin
original bug report from Jan Buchal:

emacs-snapshot: German dictionaries for ispell not works in emacs snapshot
ingerman and iogerman packages not works with ispell in emacs snapshot. 
Other package as iczech or ibritish works. Maybe the emacs-snapshot not 
match the name correctly. In emacs21 these package works.

On Tue, Apr 17, 2007 at 05:43:37PM +0900, David Smith wrote:
 Hello, I'm working on new packages of emacs-snapshot.
 
 I am not able to reproduce this bug. I installed ingerman and tested the 
 spelling of the word Rechtschreibung and was told by ispell-word 
 that RECHTSCHREIBUNG is correct because of root RECHTSCHREIBEN which I 
 assume is correct behavior. Removing one letter gives a prompt to replace the 
 word with the correct Rechtschreibung.
 
 I tested with ispell 3.1.20.0-4.3 and ingerman 20051113-5.


Reviewing bug reports after Martin call,

* Subject: RFH: Removals - emacs-snapshot
* 407119: important: emacs-snapshot: German dictionaries for ispell not works 
in emacs snapshot

Note that emacs-snapshot selects aspell as default, so you might indeed be
using aspell instead of ispell unless you explicitely select ispell. aspell
selection mechanisn in emacs-snapshot is completely independent from ispell
one and will take care of german namings.

German entries in emacs-snapshot look for 'deutsch' hash while ngerman
provides 'ndeutsch', this seems to be the reason for the problem, which I
can reproduce (deutsch is not shown in the dicts list).

This does not happen in emacs21, since it uses the dictionaries-common
patched ispell.el and associated files, pointing to the really installed
dicts. 

emacs-snapshot does not use this mechanism, we (Roman Francoise and
dictionaries-common maintainers) decided that being a development snapshot,
emacs-snapshot shoud be kept as pristine as possible wrt to dicts, so all
problems are shown.

Possible workarounds from the user side, 

* link deutsch.hash to ndeutsch.hash
* Add an user entry in your .emacs file to ispell-local-dictionary-alist

emacs22 uses dictionaries-common (old) patched ispell.el, so things should
work here. I have been doing some work to integrate new ispell.el from
emacs-cvs so it works with xemacs21 ans emacs21 as well, but that is not
at all complete.

So this is an emacs-snapshot only bug.

-- 
Agustin


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Bug#407119: emacs-snapshot: German dictionaries for ispell not works in emacs snapshot

2007-04-17 Thread David Smith
Hello, I'm working on new packages of emacs-snapshot.

I am not able to reproduce this bug. I installed ingerman and tested the 
spelling of the word Rechtschreibung and was told by ispell-word 
that RECHTSCHREIBUNG is correct because of root RECHTSCHREIBEN which I 
assume is correct behavior. Removing one letter gives a prompt to replace the 
word with the correct Rechtschreibung.

I tested with ispell 3.1.20.0-4.3 and ingerman 20051113-5.

What sort of error do you get?

Thanks,
-- 
=
  David D. Smith davidsmith at acm.org
Jabber/GoogleTalk: dds at jabber.org ; GPG: 0xE6511C7E
IRC: dds on irc.freenode.net ; MSN: dds4418 at hotmail.com
==


pgpohp6RwENu9.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Bug#407119: emacs-snapshot: German dictionaries for ispell not works in emacs snapshot

2007-04-17 Thread Sven Joachim
[David, please CC the bug submitter if you want him to answer.
 He doesn't automatically receive mails sent to the bug number.]

David Smith writes:
 Hello, I'm working on new packages of emacs-snapshot.
 
 I am not able to reproduce this bug. I installed ingerman and tested the 
 spelling of the word Rechtschreibung and was told by ispell-word 
 that RECHTSCHREIBUNG is correct because of root RECHTSCHREIBEN which I 
 assume is correct behavior. Removing one letter gives a prompt to replace the 
 word with the correct Rechtschreibung.
 
 I tested with ispell 3.1.20.0-4.3 and ingerman 20051113-5.
 
 What sort of error do you get?

I cannot reproduce the bug either. Jan, can you give more info?
What are the values of ispell-program-name and ispell-current-dictionary?

Thanks,

Sven


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]