Bug#858294: Unreproducible, moreinfo needed
forwarded 858294 https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-68380 tag 858294 - moreinfo thanks El miércoles, 11 de abril de 2018 18:11:25 -03 Vladimir Berezenko escribió: > Lisandro Dami?n Nicanor P?rez Meyer wrote: > > > This is definitely reproducible. The current Qt5 version is 5.9.2-2 on > > > my > > > quad G5, and 5.8.4 on G4 powerbook. Both machines are not reacting on > > > mousewheel events at all. I've tried KDE, LXQt. GTK2/3 apps are not > > > affected at all. > > > > Well, this is totally strange, as the only report we have heard so far is > > from you. > > This might be because others are not using Qt5 at all. It's strange, but > understandable in case that newer Qt5 is using chromium as a web backend and > it is not compileable to anything except x86 and arm and this renders Qt5 > almost unusable in modern cases. While I agree that using chromium is not a great idea I still have to mae the point that there are lots of apps using Qt5 without the webengine submodule. So I tstill think it's weird we have only heard this from you so far. > > I understand that you tried on two machines. Just to be clear: have you > > tried with a new user? > > The older installation on G5 is working the same in all users (tried new > one). The G4 installation on powerbook is the fresh one. ACK > > There is the chance that you might have configured something in the same > > way in both machines. If you still can reproduce this bug with a new user > > then we can file a bug upstream. > > Both installations are independent and on older one (G5 one) I've tried > several users. ACK. > > Actually you should do it yourself, as I don't have any ways of > > reproducing > > this bug. Please file the upstream bug at https://bugreports.qt.io and > > then > > please send the bug number here. I'll happily subscribe to the bug to > > follow it and, if possible at all, help. > > Reading the bugs there I've found that it is possible that the problem is in > QXcbAtom::ButtonWheel* wrong detection. I'm yet unable to find how does Qt5 > detects wheel buttons and where from it is getting the mouse events. The > xinput shows everything ok, and Qt4 and GTK2/3 apps all are using the wheel > perfectly > Regarding the bugreport. I should register on the site and when I will fill > bug report I'll attach it here. Done, the URL is on the first line of the mail's body. -- "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" Arthur C. Clarke Lisandro Damián Nicanor Pérez Meyer http://perezmeyer.com.ar/ http://perezmeyer.blogspot.com/ signature.asc Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
Bug#858294: Unreproducible, moreinfo needed
> > This is definitely reproducible. The current Qt5 version is 5.9.2-2 on my > > quad G5, and 5.8.4 on G4 powerbook. Both machines are not reacting on > > mousewheel events at all. I've tried KDE, LXQt. GTK2/3 apps are not > > affected at all. > Well, this is totally strange, as the only report we have heard so far is > from you. This might be because others are not using Qt5 at all. It's strange, but understandable in case that newer Qt5 is using chromium as a web backend and it is not compileable to anything except x86 and arm and this renders Qt5 almost unusable in modern cases. > I understand that you tried on two machines. Just to be clear: have you > tried with a new user? The older installation on G5 is working the same in all users (tried new one). The G4 installation on powerbook is the fresh one. > There is the chance that you might have configured something in the same way > in both machines. If you still can reproduce this bug with a new user then > we can file a bug upstream. Both installations are independent and on older one (G5 one) I've tried several users. > Actually you should do it yourself, as I don't have any ways of reproducing > this bug. Please file the upstream bug at https://bugreports.qt.io and then > please send the bug number here. I'll happily subscribe to the bug to follow > it and, if possible at all, help. Reading the bugs there I've found that it is possible that the problem is in QXcbAtom::ButtonWheel* wrong detection. I'm yet unable to find how does Qt5 detects wheel buttons and where from it is getting the mouse events. The xinput shows everything ok, and Qt4 and GTK2/3 apps all are using the wheel perfectly Regarding the bugreport. I should register on the site and when I will fill bug report I'll attach it here. -- WBR, Vladimir Berezenko
Bug#858294: Unreproducible, moreinfo needed
El jueves, 29 de marzo de 2018 14:07:02 -03 Vladimir Berezenko escribió: > > Hi! I definitely can't reproduce this bug. Can you still reproduce it? > > Which Qt version are you currently using? > > This is definitely reproducible. The current Qt5 version is 5.9.2-2 on my > quad G5, and 5.8.4 on G4 powerbook. Both machines are not reacting on > mousewheel events at all. I've tried KDE, LXQt. GTK2/3 apps are not > affected at all. Well, this is totally strange, as the only report we have heard so far is from you. I understand that you tried on two machines. Just to be clear: have you tried with a new user? There is the chance that you might have configured something in the same way in both machines. If you still can reproduce this bug with a new user then we can file a bug upstream. Actually you should do it yourself, as I don't have any ways of reproducing this bug. Please file the upstream bug at https://bugreports.qt.io and then please send the bug number here. I'll happily subscribe to the bug to follow it and, if possible at all, help. Thanks, Lisandro. -- “If you want to finish university, you should take care about getting on with the teachers. The result are submissive citizens that won’t face authority even if they know they’re right, in order to avoid problems“ Miriam Ruiz, http://www.miriamruiz.es/weblog/?p=187 Lisandro Damián Nicanor Pérez Meyer http://perezmeyer.com.ar/ http://perezmeyer.blogspot.com/ signature.asc Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
Bug#858294: Unreproducible, moreinfo needed
> Hi! I definitely can't reproduce this bug. Can you still reproduce it? Which > Qt version are you currently using? This is definitely reproducible. The current Qt5 version is 5.9.2-2 on my quad G5, and 5.8.4 on G4 powerbook. Both machines are not reacting on mousewheel events at all. I've tried KDE, LXQt. GTK2/3 apps are not affected at all. -- WBR, Vladimir Berezenko
Bug#858294: Unreproducible, moreinfo needed
Control: tag -1 unreproducible moreinfo Hi! I definitely can't reproduce this bug. Can you still reproduce it? Which Qt version are you currently using? Thanks, Lisandro. -- Alas, I am dying beyond my means. Oscar Wilde, as he sipped champagne on his deathbed Lisandro Damián Nicanor Pérez Meyer http://perezmeyer.com.ar/ http://perezmeyer.blogspot.com/ signature.asc Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
