Bug#834373: UEFI: Fails to install to blank drive

2016-09-19 Thread Steve McIntyre
Hi Evan, and thanks for prodding about this...

On Sun, Aug 14, 2016 at 07:33:10PM -0500, Evan Cox wrote:
>Package: partman-efi
>
>As per #85 at
>https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/1418706 , I was
>asked to file this bug in Debian's bug tracker. The basic issue is that
>Ubuntu fails to install to a completely blank drive (e.g. a blank virtual
>hard disk) if installing in UEFI mode and you choose a custom partition
>layout. This bug is present in multiple Ubuntu releases, including 16.04
>LTS. Not sure which version of partman-efi this is, as I cannot actually
>install Ubuntu to check. To quote from the original report:
>
>"When doing a UEFI-mode install using the latest daily Vivid ISO (Thu Feb
>5), Ubiquity incorrectly concludes that a blank drive contains an existing
>BIOS-mode install (see error in attached screenshot).
>The resulting error dialog is also broken: none of the buttons do any thing
>when clicked: X (close button), "Go Back", "Continue".
>You can seemingly move the install forward by clicking "Continue" in the
>main installer window, but things are still broken somewhere as grub isn't
>getting correctly installed (system is unbootable after the install
>completes)."

I've just tested partman-efi right now in Debian using a blank target
drive, booting in UEFI from both DVD and from USB. I don't see any
issue myself.

How exactly did you test, please - what machine, boot media etc.? I'm
guessing this might be something caused by ubiquity, but it's not
something I've ever looked into myself as we don't use it in Debian.

-- 
Steve McIntyre, Cambridge, UK.st...@einval.com
  Mature Sporty Personal
  More Innovation More Adult
  A Man in Dandism
  Powered Midship Specialty



Bug#834373: UEFI: Fails to install to blank drive

2016-08-14 Thread Evan Cox
Package: partman-efi

As per #85 at
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubiquity/+bug/1418706 , I was
asked to file this bug in Debian's bug tracker. The basic issue is that
Ubuntu fails to install to a completely blank drive (e.g. a blank virtual
hard disk) if installing in UEFI mode and you choose a custom partition
layout. This bug is present in multiple Ubuntu releases, including 16.04
LTS. Not sure which version of partman-efi this is, as I cannot actually
install Ubuntu to check. To quote from the original report:

"When doing a UEFI-mode install using the latest daily Vivid ISO (Thu Feb
5), Ubiquity incorrectly concludes that a blank drive contains an existing
BIOS-mode install (see error in attached screenshot).
The resulting error dialog is also broken: none of the buttons do any thing
when clicked: X (close button), "Go Back", "Continue".
You can seemingly move the install forward by clicking "Continue" in the
main installer window, but things are still broken somewhere as grub isn't
getting correctly installed (system is unbootable after the install
completes)."

Thanks,
Evan