Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-09 Thread Kai Henningsen
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Brederlow) wrote on 07.05.98 in [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Rev. Joseph Carter [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: [1 text/plain; us-ascii (7bit)] On Fri, May 01, 1998 at 04:19:42PM +1000, John Boggon wrote: Can someone tell me why a new distribution has to be started up just

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-07 Thread Brederlow
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: No problem here. As I said I *DID* find the answers and got my debian installation to talk to my ethernet card after making use of available documentation. But it was not Debian specfic documentation that was most helpfull, but rather general linux networking and

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-07 Thread Brederlow
Rev. Joseph Carter [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: [1 text/plain; us-ascii (7bit)] On Fri, May 01, 1998 at 04:19:42PM +1000, John Boggon wrote: Can someone tell me why a new distribution has to be started up just because the current one isn't newbie friendly or easy to install ? There isn't

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-07 Thread Ardo van Rangelrooij
Brederlow [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: No problem here. As I said I *DID* find the answers and got my debian installation to talk to my ethernet card after making use of available documentation. But it was not Debian specfic documentation that was most

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-02 Thread Bruce Perens
From: Anthony Fok [EMAIL PROTECTED] I know you have the best intentions, but to be honest with you, I felt somewhat betrayed and abandoned when I first read your announcement. I don't blame you. Unfortunately, I think that the conflict attendant upon my (entirely theoretical) return to Debian

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-01 Thread John Boggon
Can someone tell me why a new distribution has to be started up just because the current one isn't newbie friendly or easy to install ? Why not concentrate on an installation system or front end for dpkg / APT along with a system management GUI package that can help an inexperienced sysadmin or

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-01 Thread Anthony Fok
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 12:05:00PM -0700, Bruce Perens wrote: From: Martin Schulze [EMAIL PROTECTED] [ Focus on the user issue ] This is the case for a lot of debian developers, not for all of them, I have to admit. I think it's too large a number for me to go against. Vocal Minority;

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-05-01 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Fri, May 01, 1998 at 04:19:42PM +1000, John Boggon wrote: Can someone tell me why a new distribution has to be started up just because the current one isn't newbie friendly or easy to install ? There isn't really. Why not concentrate on an installation system or front end for dpkg / APT

on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Bruce Perens
Dear Debian Folks, I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian or the commercial distributions. I've posted my first message on this topic to debian-devel, as I think a lot of you

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Raul Miller
Bruce Perens [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian or the commercial distributions. I've posted my first message on this topic to debian-devel

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Wed, Apr 29, 1998 at 08:05:00PM -0700, Bruce Perens wrote: I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian or the commercial distributions. Certainly no distribution can meet

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Bruce Perens
From: Raul Miller [EMAIL PROTECTED] (1) we probably don't want to talk about this in much depth on the debian lists, since you've explicitly stated that it's not debian. Please announce an alternative venue as soon as you can. Right. It's not my intent to abuse the Debian lists. I'll try to

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Jason Gunthorpe
On Wed, 29 Apr 1998, Bruce Perens wrote: 9. A Random List of Other Goals. RPM as the package system - possibly with an APT port later on (is that what it's called now?). It's necessary to get the other distributions in on the project. We'd have to add a few missing

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread David Welton
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 05:10:54AM +, Rev. Joseph Carter wrote: On Wed, Apr 29, 1998 at 08:05:00PM -0700, Bruce Perens wrote: I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Ean Schuessler
: I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian or the commercial distributions. 1. Focus on the User Who is the real user? An experienced hacker or a person who has

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Anthony Fok
On Wed, Apr 29, 1998 at 08:05:00PM -0700, Bruce Perens wrote: Dear Debian Folks, I've been giving serious thought for a while to forming a new Linux distribution. My reason is to fulfill some goals that currently are not addressed by Debian or the commercial distributions. I really don't

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Raul Miller
Ean Schuessler [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My personal feeling is that every man hour that Debian loses to this effort is one man hour too many. Er.. Debian is not that kind of effort. Personally, I think every hour of flamage we lose will be paid back in an order of magnitude of better

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Raul Miller
Jason Gunthorpe [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 1 - They don't actually have package dependencies. They have dependencies on files - big difference. Perhaps this could be synthesized from a complete list of all files provided by rpm, and a limited scope which prohibits presenting competing

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Kai Henningsen
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Bruce Perens) wrote on 29.04.98 in [EMAIL PROTECTED]: 1. Focus on the User I'd like to have developers who program because they like to see their work in the hands of users, especially _naive_ users. Well, I must say that while users are nice, naive users ...

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Tommi Virtanen
On Wed, Apr 29, 1998 at 08:05:00PM -0700, Bruce Perens wrote: 5. Open Development. I am proposing development visible to all, but not a free-for-all. A core group of limited size to maintain the base system and oversee the rest probably _is_ necessary. I am not planning to

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 02:33:54AM -0500, Ean Schuessler wrote: [..] Bruce could have followed the great Freeware tradition of building concensus by putting togethor a team of Debianites dedicated to creating a newbie-friendly wrapper for the technically excellent Debian distribution. [..]

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Steve Dunham
Jason Gunthorpe [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: On Wed, 29 Apr 1998, Bruce Perens wrote: As I see it there are two major problems that preclude using APT with RPM as it stands, 1 - They don't actually have package dependencies. They have dependencies on files - big difference. 2 - They

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Steve Dunham
Raul Miller [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: 2 - They seem to lack a well formed index file, I couldn't find any rpm index on their ftp site. Presumably, this could also be addressed by work. [Since it's not specific to the rpm format, but the rpm site.] There is an index file in the

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 10:06:00AM -0400, Steve Dunham wrote: It might be smart to fork rpm (call it something else) and re-do the header fields to be more sensible, then use APT to provide understanding This would be bad. Especially since RPM is a cross platform standard: people are

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Martin Schulze
Hi! What I read from Bruce here recalls a discussion on linux-kernel where Linus made the following statement: Ooh, mommy, mommy, what I have now doesn't work in this extremely unlikely circumstance, so I'll just throw it away and write something jcompletely new. -- Linus

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Stephen Carpenter
Rev. Joseph Carter wrote: On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 02:33:54AM -0500, Ean Schuessler wrote: [..] Bruce could have followed the great Freeware tradition of building concensus by putting togethor a team of Debianites dedicated to creating a newbie-friendly wrapper for the technically

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Sven Rudolph
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Bruce Perens) writes: 1. Focus on the User I'd like to have developers who program because they like to see their work in the hands of users, especially _naive_ users. You are searching developers who will put significiant time into making parts of Debian (or

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Kenneth . Scharf
If someone has the desire to install an operating system on a computer that is created, supported, and distributed by volunteers they should expect to have to do some amount of reading to configure the system to their liking. When someone does the install and then proceeds to cry because the

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Dale Scheetz
On Thu, 30 Apr 1998, Stephen Carpenter wrote: I dunno...I think ee and ae are both pretty damned easy and mindless :)(ae is sooo mindless I have noticed it is putting CR in my text documents) As it turns out the DOS CR is coming from slang and is being worked on. Ae's .rc files are currently

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Bruce Perens
BTW: What is the current state of Dominik's project (FreeLinux (?)). No messages regarding its progress or lack thereof for the past year. Real developers tend to disklike marketing. Don't tell that to my colleauges at Pixar. Or most other commercial firms. As far as I can tell they only

RE: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Patrick Ouellette
neighbor, but you can't ping your neighborÂ’s node. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, April 30, 1998 12:02 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; debian-devel@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution If someone has the desire

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread john
Ean Schuessler wrote: [..] Bruce could have followed the great Freeware tradition of building concensus by putting togethor a team of Debianites dedicated to creating a newbie-friendly wrapper for the technically excellent Debian distribution. [..] Rev. Joseph Carter wrote: If there are a

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Bruce Perens
From: Martin Schulze [EMAIL PROTECTED] What I read from Bruce here recalls a discussion on linux-kernel where Linus made the following statement: Ooh, mommy, mommy, what I have now doesn't work in this extremely unlikely circumstance, so I'll just throw it away and write something

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 04:35:24PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: [1] The KDE team produces a lot of them like kppp, kisdn, kheise etc. I don't believe that these is the answer as long as Qt is non-free but it's a way in the right direction. My personal hesitation with Qt has been

Re: on forming a new Linux Distribution

1998-04-30 Thread Rev. Joseph Carter
On Thu, Apr 30, 1998 at 10:44:21AM -0400, Stephen Carpenter wrote: [Debian for the clueless users] If there are a group of people interested in doing this still, I am very much interested in seeing this done and contributing what I can to the project. I find this idea interesting and