Bug#878332: linux > 4.11: Raspberry pi 2 hangs at boot with lpae kernel
On 10.09.20 at 18:34, Gunnar Wolf wrote: > At the time of my bug report, I had not tested it yet. I checked right > now, downloading an image from raspi.debian.net, and installing the > -lpae kernel, I can confirm it boots correctly all the way to: > > root@rpi2-20200910:~# uname -a > Linux rpi2-20200910 4.19.0-10-armmp-lpae #1 SMP Debian 4.19.132-1 > (2020-07-24) armv7l GNU/Linux Thanks again for testing :-) signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Bug#878332: linux > 4.11: Raspberry pi 2 hangs at boot with lpae kernel
Philip Rinn dijo [Thu, Sep 10, 2020 at 12:09:29PM +0200]: > Hi Gunnar, > > thanks for testing - but your message leaves me a little confused. You claim, > the > bug is fixed but you say > > > we have used only regular linux-image-armmp kernels (and have no > > reason to suppose -lpae is needed). > > So, my question, did you actually test with an "-lpae" kernel? At the time of my bug report, I had not tested it yet. I checked right now, downloading an image from raspi.debian.net, and installing the -lpae kernel, I can confirm it boots correctly all the way to: root@rpi2-20200910:~# uname -a Linux rpi2-20200910 4.19.0-10-armmp-lpae #1 SMP Debian 4.19.132-1 (2020-07-24) armv7l GNU/Linux > While being technically correct that an "-lpae" kernel is not needed, the > kernel > should still also work on an rpi2 _with_ an "-lpae" kernel. OK, I'm happy to have understood this correctly :-) signature.asc Description: PGP signature
Bug#878332: linux > 4.11: Raspberry pi 2 hangs at boot with lpae kernel
Hi Gunnar, thanks for testing - but your message leaves me a little confused. You claim, the bug is fixed but you say > we have used only regular linux-image-armmp kernels (and have no > reason to suppose -lpae is needed). So, my question, did you actually test with an "-lpae" kernel? While being technically correct that an "-lpae" kernel is not needed, the kernel should still also work on an rpi2 _with_ an "-lpae" kernel. Best, Philip signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Bug#878332: linux > 4.11: Raspberry pi 2 hangs at boot with lpae kernel
fixed 878332 4.19.132-1 fixed 878332 5.7.17-1 thanks Hello, This bug is no longer present in kernels shipped in Debian stable / testing / unstable. Do note, though, that the Raspberry Pi 2 is sold with 1GB RAM only and cannot be upgraded, and thus has no use for LPAE, we have used only regular linux-image-armmp kernels (and have no reason to suppose -lpae is needed). signature.asc Description: PGP signature
