Re: Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-08-08 Thread Branden Robinson
On Sat, Jul 31, 2004 at 09:57:35PM +0100, Andrew Suffield wrote: US law does not require choice of law clauses, so long as the prosecuting party can in some sense claim to be in the US. Even if they're a foreign multinational who just has an office there. They can blithely apply their laws to

Re: Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-08-02 Thread Anthony DeRobertis
On Sat, Jul 31, 2004 at 08:53:07AM -0400, Michael Poole wrote: Anthony DeRobertis writes: Obviously debian-legal isn't a place to get legal advice, and I think most lawyers would demand more details before giving legal advice, so take all this with a grain of salt. Of course. With choice

Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-07-31 Thread Anthony DeRobertis
I'm not fully sure how those clauses work. Cites are welcome. Anyway, I have two hypothetical scenarios to consider. In both cases, let's say the software is licensed under an arbitrary free license; perhaps the MIT X11 license. FIRST SCENARIO -- Let's say there is a piece of

Re: Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-07-31 Thread Michael Poole
Anthony DeRobertis writes: FIRST SCENARIO -- Let's say there is a piece of software who's author, Arthur, resides in France (or many other European countries with similar laws). A US resident, Jim, decides to modify the software to use it as Nazi propaganda. [How exactly he

Re: Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-07-31 Thread Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS
Anthony DeRobertis [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Lastly, if there is a choice of venue clause, can Arthur force Tom to appear in France, where he could be arrested for violating French hate-speech laws? I don't think you have to appear in person for a civil case. However, it has just occurred to me

Re: Quick(?) Questions on Choice of Law Venue

2004-07-31 Thread Andrew Suffield
On Sat, Jul 31, 2004 at 08:05:08AM -0400, Anthony DeRobertis wrote: FIRST SCENARIO -- Let's say there is a piece of software who's author, Arthur, resides in France (or many other European countries with similar laws). A US resident, Jim, decides to modify the software to use