Re: Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

Actually the redacted link [https://cliapp.store/apps/transity/] says it is paid product. So in this case the bad intent you mentioned apply. -- An old man doll... just what I always wanted! - Clara

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

* Andrej Shadura: > On Fri, 20 Dec 2019 at 10:48, Bagas Sanjaya wrote: >> >> But again I say that this program is GPL-licensed, but it can be used >> freely (of charge) for non commercial purposes only, but proprietary >> (one must purchase license) for commercial use. >> >> So I think this

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

Em sexta-feira, 20 de dezembro de 2019, Bagas Sanjaya escreveu: > > Transity is licensed under GPL-3.0-or-later and can be used free of charge >> at non-profits and for evaluation. For long-term usage, however, please >> make sure to purchase a license at [link redacted]. >> > > IMO it is not

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

On 15622 March 1977, Bagas Sanjaya wrote: Recently I stumble upon Transity [https://github.com/feramhq/transity], a plain-text accounting system a la (H)Ledger. However, when I saw the README, it says: Transity is licensed under GPL-3.0-or-later and can be used free of charge at non-profits

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

So I agree that the language, as worded, seems like it might not be binding... But it at least reflects a contradictory intent, if not a hard contradiction. The licensors are certainly confused. Has somebody tried contacting them to clarify their intent? On Fri, Dec 20, 2019, 06:44 Roberto

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

There was a similar case with LinuxSampler a few years ago, restricting *use* of the program in commercial applications. It was removed from Debian and it was concluded that its license is inconsistent, nobody can actually comply with it, because the GPL and the added restriction contradict each

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

How can I contact FTP masters team for asking this issue? I prefer not via IRC. On 20/12/19 17.43, Andrej Shadura wrote: Hi, On Fri, 20 Dec 2019, 11:42 Bagas Sanjaya, > wrote: So is it DFSG-Free and can be included in Debian main? On 20/12/19 17.05,

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

So is it DFSG-Free and can be included in Debian main? On 20/12/19 17.05, Andrej Shadura wrote: Hi, On Fri, 20 Dec 2019 at 10:48, Bagas Sanjaya wrote: But again I say that this program is GPL-licensed, but it can be used freely (of charge) for non commercial purposes only, but proprietary

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

But again I say that this program is GPL-licensed, but it can be used freely (of charge) for non commercial purposes only, but proprietary (one must purchase license) for commercial use. So I think this could violate DFSG #6, right? On 20/12/19 16.21, Mihai Moldovan wrote: * On 12/20/19 9:59

Re: Transity: GPL-licensed but Free only for Non-Commercials

* On 12/20/19 9:59 AM, Bagas Sanjaya wrote: > Recently I stumble upon Transity [https://github.com/feramhq/transity], > a plain-text accounting system a la (H)Ledger. > > However, when I saw the README, it says: > >> Transity is licensed under GPL-3.0-or-later and can be used free of charge >>