[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2014-09-21 Thread Julien Olivier
Now that there's an Ubuntu-Gnome distribution, the patch should be reverted so that Rhythmbox works as expected in Ubuntu-GNOME. And stock Ubuntu should fix Rhythmbox by having a rhythmbox-unity package or something like that. There's no reason why GNOME users shuld suffer from Unity's behaviour.

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2010-09-16 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Importance: Unknown = Medium -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2009-05-18 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: New = Fix Released -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2009-01-19 Thread b2ag
On my Ubuntu 8.10 PC activating a Rhythmbox-plugin called minimize to tray solved this issue. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. --

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2009-01-01 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
No it's not properly fixed, I was wrong, the situation is always the same. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2009-01-01 Thread Christian Apolloni
There should be a plugin available in rhythmbox to switch to the desired behaviour. As far as I understand this is the most we will ever get (and it is enough for me at least). -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-12-31 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Isn't this properly fixed in intrepid? AFAIR (I am not using ubuntu right now - since I am not on my PC) rhythmbox has now no icon by default. If you enable the notification area plugin then it minimises. This is in my opinion a very good fix - but maybe I remember one thing for another :) --

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-12-29 Thread bealer
Definitely a bug or inconsistency in my opinion. As mentioned something like Pidgin, if I select close or click the x it just minimizes. Rhythmbox seems to be the only app that goes against this. Hence I see it as a bug as it's not consistent with other apps. -- Window close should close, not

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-09-25 Thread Creak
@Vincenzo Ciancia: Just to be sure, you think devs should add a button instead of a plugin? If that's it, I actually completely agree with you. At least, there is the plugin now. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-09-25 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
In my opinion, there should be consistency among all gnome apps, so the default should be not quitting but closing, for reason that I longly explained. If I have to resort to a preference, I personally don't care if it's a plugin or a hidden setting or whatever: I will be able to choose what I

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-09-25 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Just to be constructive I could add that a different _proper_ solution to me seems the following: just don't have a notification area icon by default. Thus, rhythmbox would act like totem and no inconsistency would be experienced. This bug is already fix-released and I shouldn't be commenting

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-23 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox (Debian) Status: Confirmed = Fix Released -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-14 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
As a final note to this bug, there is an ubuntu brainstorm idea for this http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/5488/ -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Åskar
The bug is fixed upstream http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=318629 -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Sebastien Bacher
right, this has been discussed on IRC this morning in a constructive way -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Christian Apolloni
Sebastien, do you know if it's possible to get a log of the discussion and where? I am quite interested in it. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Sebastien Bacher
there is nothing interesting in the log, upstream agreed that the plugin was a good option but just didn't want to commit due to the users attitude on the bug, he suggested that somebody else should do the commit instead -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
My fault, I overlooked the upstream bug report. It was fixed by adding the relevant plugin. Very good. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber.

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
How has this bug been fixed? Was it finally decided to leave an option to the user and which is the default? This is very good news in any case. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Launchpad Bug Tracker
This bug was fixed in the package rhythmbox - 0.11.5.90-0ubuntu1 --- rhythmbox (0.11.5.90-0ubuntu1) intrepid; urgency=low * New upstream pre-version: - Relicensed with GPL exception for GStreamer plugins - Improvements to the cross-fading playback backend - Use Amazon

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Richard Laager
I'm glad the option has shown up. I think turning it on by default would be good for Ubuntu (in terms of consistency), but I don't care to debate this any more than saying that. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Il giorno mer, 02/07/2008 alle 15.08 +, Sebastien Bacher ha scritto: there is nothing interesting in the log, upstream agreed that the plugin was a good option but just didn't want to commit due to the users attitude on the bug On this bug report, I see a constructive discussion, getting

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Sebastien Bacher
the issue is not this one, but that's not because you disagree with whoever is writting the code that you have rights to rant at him or to comment in a not correct way the code is open and the people who are working on it can take whatever choice they want, they work on their free time, don't

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Christian Apolloni
Sebastien, As you said, developers are free to do what they want, but this does not mean users are not allowed to complain when they believe developers are wrong or are behaving in an unprofessional way. It is perfectly right for a user to express his opinion, even in a very direct way, and I

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Sebastien Bacher
why should people who are hobbists and working for free should behave in a professional way? the comment was not a reply to your contribution but some people have not been correct in their behaviour and that's what created the conflict. everybody will agree than discussion and good sense usually

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Christian Apolloni
why should people who are hobbists and working for free should behave in a professional way? To avoid unnecessary attrition with the users. To have constructive discussions with the goal of improving the software under development. To avoid negative energy as you called it. In my opinion these

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-02 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Il giorno mer, 02/07/2008 alle 20.29 +, Sebastien Bacher ha scritto: why should people who are hobbists and working for free should behave in a professional way? That's ok Sebastien, that's why I in principle did not bother quarrelling upstream and asked for a choice in ubuntu, like for

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-01 Thread Christian Apolloni
The upstream bug has been closed with WONTFIX. Last comment was: Comment #46 from Jonathan Matthew (rhythmbox developer, points: 23) 2008-07-01 22:16 UTC [reply] I am tired of even thinking about this issue. In future, I'm not even going to comment on it (or anything related), let alone

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-01 Thread Alexander Jones
For anyone interested, I've put a fork of RB on GitHub, with this change applied. I'll continue to pull updates from Rhythmbox until I get bored. http://github.com/alex-weej/boombox/tree/master -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-01 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox (Debian) Status: Unknown = Confirmed -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-01 Thread Richard Laager
** Bug watch added: Debian Bug tracker #280924 http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=280924 ** Also affects: rhythmbox (Debian) via http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=280924 Importance: Unknown Status: Unknown -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-07-01 Thread Richard Laager
This can be patched in Ubuntu pretty easily. We just need to drop this file in debian/patches (as 20_close_to_tray.patch or something): http://bugzilla.gnome.org/attachment.cgi?id=70929action=view -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
If the patch has been merged upstream (I don't care if using a plugin) then I am fine with that. For consistency with other applications, this should be enabled by default but I guess you can't ask too much. What I understood in principle was that the patch had not been accepted upstream, if it

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Sebastien Bacher
could everybody stop comment spamming this bug? the default will not be changed because some vocal users decided to add lot of comments there some comments though: - the notification area is not made to have applications staying there - consistancy is good, but do you have many applications not

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Christian Apolloni
Sebastien, I'd like to address some of your comments: could everybody stop comment spamming this bug? the default will not be changed because some vocal users decided to add lot of comments there I don't care about the default, I care about having an option. We are vocal because the option is

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
** Changed in: rhythmbox Bugwatch: GNOME Bug Tracker #318629 = GNOME Bug Tracker #532313 Status: Won't Fix = Unknown -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: Unknown = Invalid -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
** Changed in: rhythmbox Bugwatch: GNOME Bug Tracker #532313 = GNOME Bug Tracker #158168 Status: Invalid = Unknown -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Sebastien Bacher
It is obvious to me that when different users wish different reasonable behaviours you offer choice, that's what made a lot of people vocal about all of this story. This seems not obvious to the rhythmbox developers and at least I cannot figure out why. could be that you are using the wrong

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: Unknown = New -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Christian Apolloni
Sebastien, - launchpad is a distribution bug tracker and people who read your comments are packagers and bug triagers, not people who writte this code Since from upstream it is not clear if and when at least the plugin will be released I just asked for a fix included in the distribution package:

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Sebastien Bacher
the comment was not especially about your contribution but a note for the people ranting on this bug, your comment upstream is mostly constructive though nobody claims to know better, whoever is writting the software is just free to take the choice he wants for his code and being agressive to

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Christian Apolloni
the comment was not especially about your contribution but a note for the people ranting on this bug, your comment upstream is mostly constructive though nobody claims to know better, whoever is writting the software is just free to take the choice he wants for his code and being agressive to

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Jonathan Hitchcock
As has been pointed out right at the top of the thread, GNOME has very clear rules and guidelines about how applications should behave in order to fit in with the rest of the environment: http://developer.gnome.org/projects/gup/hig/ Currently, Rhythmbox violates those guidelines, as clearly

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Maxim Levitsky
Btw transmission doesn't close too, when clicking on close button. I don't remember any 'background' application that does Even in KDE Please add an option to rhytmbox, and thats all and lets move forward, We users don't ask to remove an option, or even change an option, but just add it and

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Il giorno lun, 30/06/2008 alle 07.46 +, Sebastien Bacher ha scritto: some comments though: - the notification area is not made to have applications staying there - consistancy is good, but do you have many applications not closing when you close those? that's rather pidgin and the reboot

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Il giorno lun, 30/06/2008 alle 09.08 +, Sebastien Bacher ha scritto: - you will not convince people who are working for free on the code and trying to fix your issues by being vocal or rant, quite the contrary - the issue is usually that people working on free software projects are really

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Sebastien Bacher
the 8 comments added on saturday don't bring any value to the bug and I consider that spamming the people subscribed to the bug, that's what this pointless discussion do too so I'll stop contributing to it now, some notes though: - giving urls to other website or blog entry is not considered as

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Alexander Jones
Sebastian -- both a complete GConf option, documented et al, and a plugin are available on the upstream Bugzilla. The fact is that Jon Matthews doesn't like the idea at all, and is clearly reluctant to distribute either. -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-30 Thread Christian Apolloni
Sebastien, among the 8 comments you mention there is described a workaround which interested users (I guess every users who is interested in this bug) can use to get what they want quickly and somewhat painlessly. They also made clear that a fix at ubuntu level is unlikely, even if I would find

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread Christian Apolloni
Alleluja! There is a plugin which does not require patches to rhythmbox itself! My bad I didn't get it... You can get it from there: http://methlab42.itee.uq.edu.au/~jonathan/rhythmbox-plugins/dontreallyclose/ If you prefer I changed it a bit to get the correct animation when hiding the window:

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread Simone Tolotti
Hi, Christian ,as said upstream, your version of the plugin doesnpt work for me! It correctly minimize to tray when clicking on close button, but I can't restore the window clicking on the tray icon... No issues with the original version of the plugin. -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread Christian Apolloni
You're right, I'm sorry. Please disregard my version, I'll try to get it working later. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread erlguta
Thanks Vicenza for this patch so desired. But to be a version rhythmbox_0.11.5-0ubuntu6 + quickfix1_i386.deb and sources of official 0.11.5-0ubuntu8 always asks for upgrade... Is there any way to resolve this? It is incredible that something so trivial, so simple and so necessary to give this

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread Christian Apolloni
erlguta, you can upgrade to the new (unpatched) version ad use the plugin from http://methlab42.itee.uq.edu.au/~jonathan/rhythmbox-plugins/dontreallyclose/ -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-29 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: In Progress = Won't Fix -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Il giorno sab, 28/06/2008 alle 04.14 +, Ian ha scritto: I should be consistent like every other popular music app on Linux Amarok, Listen, Banshee... it should close to the tray icon. It *does* seem to me like developers are just waiting for people to forget this. Just asking for a

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread bsolar
Vincenzo, I understand your disappointment but I don't think the developers are waiting for people to forget. This issue has been fixed upstream with a trivial patch wich adds a gconf option, so the developers did do something about this problem (even if it took a long battle for this...). What

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread Parthan
Sorry that we could see some frustration building up over the bug's status. As you can see, it has been confirmed, triagged and in progress, which means you have indeed got some attention over this bug. As bsolar points out, may be it needs to be backported to the existing version in Hardy. Let's

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread Alexander Jones
Go and yell upstream, I very much doubt Ubuntu will be shipping this feature as a distribution patch. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. --

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread Christian Apolloni
Alexander, I very much doubt Ubuntu will be shipping this feature as a distribution patch. Is there a particular reason for this? -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs,

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-28 Thread Alexander Jones
No, just my experience. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list desktop-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-27 Thread Maxim Levitsky
So when this is going to be fixed? I am also tired of this bug. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-27 Thread Ian
I agree... PLEASE fix this. This is just ridiculous... I know its minor, but its my biggest gripe about rhythmbox. I should be consistent like every other popular music app on Linux Amarok, Listen, Banshee... it should close to the tray icon. -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-06-25 Thread bsolar
Would it be possible to add this patch to the rhythmbox package shipped with ubuntu? This bug is more than 2 years old and there is a trivial fix... -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-05-11 Thread Ripfox
Bravo for the patch...much better, thanks! -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list desktop-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-26 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Here is the new ppa. The ubuntu-quickfix team is open to provide simple and widely requested cures like this one, please join if you can do that. To get rhythmbox that minimizes to tray instead of exiting, use the sources.list line in the page below or download .deb archives directly from there.

Re: [Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-26 Thread Alexander Jones
I have patched this upstream as a gconf option weeks ago. It's on the upstream report. Save the effort. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber.

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-26 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Alexander: in which version of gnome will this end? Will it hit hardy or intrepid? -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-26 Thread end-user
I'm so tired of losing my random track or having to re-buffer my radio feed because I accidentally close Rhythmbox. This happens 2-3 times a session. Minimizing to tray on close, honestly, should simply be the default behaviour. It is just common sense. Barring that, there should at least be an

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-26 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
I attach the obvious 4 lines patch that fixes this bug. Notice there's a TODO to make it an option. I don't think an option would be of any use here but if any of you can come with code I will add it to my patch. I will upload the fixed package to a new PPA as soon as possible, this means that

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-25 Thread Johnny Proton
RIDICULOUS!!! Every other application that resides in the system tray (or whatever it is called in Ubuntu) minimizes to that tray when the X in the upper right of the application window is clicked. Only Rythmbox actually quits when I click that button. This has been a problem for years and

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-25 Thread Johnny Proton
It should be a Gnome thing, but the Gnome Apps should shre a comon interface and behavior Rythmbox could exily fix in their own code and at least the platform would be consistent. Make it a law later, because everyone agrees. -- Window close should close, not quit

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-05 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: Confirmed = In Progress -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-04-04 Thread Alexander Jones
The current behaviour is a massive usability disaster. Scenario: I'm listening to music, RB's main window is hidden. I click the RB icon, and the window shows up. I close the window. My music stops. Huh? -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-03-02 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
I don't have the necessary time. If some of you could prepare a patch for the ubuntu package, we can distribute the package trough a ppa on launchpad in the meantime and see if people likes it. Patch should be trivial but as I said I don't personally have the time to look into details. -- Window

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-03-01 Thread beaver82
i think close in system tray option is a must for a system tray program, i'm looking forward for it -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. --

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-03-01 Thread Simone Tolotti
I'm impressed by the blindness of rhythmbox developers. It's about 1 year that it's been discussed. Don't you think that this worth an option to choose if you want to close or minimize to tray, when you click window's close button? I think this should be true for every app that has a reason to

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2008-02-28 Thread sockopen
I have now just removed Rhythmbox because of the way it exits and not closes, I was okay with it not having an equalizer (though that did bother me), exiting instead of closing is absolutely intolerable. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-12-01 Thread Stanislav Lyahnovich
I think than i will be very good if i can choose what application should do, considering that different peoples has different opinions. It should be a preference option that will control behavior of Close (button with crosshair). By default it should be turned off, so never versions of application

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-25 Thread Bug Watch Updater
** Changed in: rhythmbox Status: Invalid = Confirmed -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs mailing list

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-25 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
I am just calling for a comment on the hig violation I mentioned, that closing a window should not cause an object in the panel to disappear. For what I understand about tray icons and the intended behavior of rhythmbox, this application shouldn't have a tray icon at all. In any case, I don't

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-25 Thread Sebastien Bacher
the notification area is not made for daemon but for notifications as suggested by its naming -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. --

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-25 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Still, the HIG violation is there. However, I should ask this question on the gnome bug tracker, not here, because violating the HIG is an issue of gnome, not ubuntu. I will do that ASAP. -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-25 Thread Sebastien Bacher
note that the HIG is a set of guidelines not rules that applications have to apply -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Desktop Bugs, which is a direct subscriber. -- desktop-bugs

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-24 Thread Sebastien Bacher
rhythmbox has one window and there is no reason you should close it and than have to go to the systray and right click there to stop using it, there is no consensus there, you should rather argue upstream on bugzilla.gnome.org ** Changed in: rhythmbox (Ubuntu) Importance: Medium = Wishlist

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-22 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
All applications I know that have an icon in the system tray can show a window when clicked, but closing that window will not make the application quit or the icon disappear from the systray. Is it ok to close a window, but the application in this context is represented by the systray icon, like

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-22 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
Ok, I've read other discussions on the gnome bug tracker. Not going to surrender :) Sorry for causing trouble here, but I really think I am seeing a mistake in gnome, and would like to see it corrected. So let me summarize the two most important points that have been overlooked, apart from

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-22 Thread Stefan Wagner
The first application I met which didn't close, but minimized to the tray, was skype, and that was confusing for me. Why didn't it close? Close has allways meant close. Minimize was minimize. IMHO a program should provide an extra systray-icon, if wanted. rhythmbox is doing right - the others

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-22 Thread Vincenzo Ciancia
What do you mean with IMHO a program should provide an extra systray- icon, if wanted ? That users should be able to choose whether to have or not a systray icon? Anyways, stefan: before skype, did you ever see any other application which installed a systray icon when launched using menus? **

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-22 Thread Richard Laager
Yes, Close has allways (sic) meant close, and minimize has always meant minimize. Furthermore, quit has always meant quit. Why on earth would the close button mean quit on an application that has other objects open? Closing the buddy list in Pidgin shouldn't close all the conversation windows any

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-09 Thread simontol
Adding an option in preferences could solve this... Listen for examlple has a close in system tray option that you can enable. Please move this to wishlist... -- Window close should close, not quit https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/38512 You received this bug notification because you are a member

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2007-09-09 Thread Richard Laager
This came up again with Pidgin... (12:52:57) John Bailey (rekkanoryo): I can think of AIM, yahoo, windows live messenger, mozilla seamonkey, I believe myspaceim, and a bunch of others whose names aren't occurring to me right now that force the default of close button == send to tray icon Also,

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-06-12 Thread RichardQuirk
** Bug 49483 has been marked a duplicate of this bug -- Window close should close, not quit https://launchpad.net/bugs/38512 -- desktop-bugs mailing list desktop-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/desktop-bugs

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-06-06 Thread Sebastien Bacher
** Bug 48590 has been marked a duplicate of this bug -- Window close should close, not quit https://launchpad.net/bugs/38512 -- desktop-bugs mailing list desktop-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/desktop-bugs

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-05-16 Thread Richard Laager
** Bug watch added: GNOME Bug Tracker #342049 http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=342049 ** Also affects: rhythmbox (upstream) via http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=342049 Severity: Unknown Priority: Unknown Status: Unknown -- Window close should close, not

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-04-22 Thread Sebastien Bacher
having the behaviour changing between boxes and applications is just confusing, what is your issue with having the close button closing an application? -- Window close should close, not quit https://launchpad.net/bugs/38512 -- desktop-bugs mailing list desktop-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-04-22 Thread Richard Laager
Applications that have a tray icon are generally long-running. (Why else would they have the ability to minimize to tray?) Thus, the desired behavior when I close that window is that the application keep going. The desired behavior when I close other apps (say Firefox, GnuCash, OpenOffice.org,

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-04-21 Thread Sebastien Bacher
Thanks for your bug. The close button is supposed to close the application, that's a feature not a bug, I'm rejecting it since that's not a bug ** Changed in: rhythmbox (Ubuntu) Assignee: (unassigned) = Ubuntu Desktop Bugs Status: Unconfirmed = Rejected -- Window close should close,

[Bug 38512] Re: Window close should close, not quit

2006-04-21 Thread Richard Laager
I disagree. Look at what Gaim does in the same situation. With rhythmbox, if I click minimize, it minimizes to the tray. If I click close, it quits. There is no way that I can see to minimize it to the tray from the application itself. I have to go up and hit the tray icon. This consequently

  1   2   >