[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-21 Thread Paul Sladen
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** How exactly did you make the volume-up button trigger both thinkpad- mixer-up and soundcard-mixer-up ? I think for edgy what I'll do is have a daemon that listens for changes to the ALSA state and syncs these back to the hardware. So the hardware

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-21 Thread Martin Emrich
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** I did not do anything to trigger this behaviour. Out-of-the box (more- or-less, as my notebook was installed with the dapper development branch a long time ago, and is constantly updated), I already had the weird behaviour, that the Thinkpad buttons

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-20 Thread Paul Sladen
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** Martin: Okay, I think what you're highlighting is this: Mute = hardware mute-set regardless VolumeDown/VolumeUp = Unmute and this is [almost] the same as 'gnome-settings-daemon', which takes the first movement (Up or Down) after a mute as also

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-20 Thread Martin Emrich
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** It was not my intention to highlight this, but now as you explain it, the behaviour makes sense. As I see it: lshal -m does not dump events generated by buttons, but rather what some layer in between makes of the button presses. My opinion is that

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-12 Thread Martin Emrich
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** Oops, I forgot: I use both Kubuntu and Ubuntu, Dapper Drake development branch (my Desktop environment is GNOME, but I installed KDE, too, and use kontact as my pim...) Ciao Martin -- ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-11 Thread Paul Sladen
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** Martin: you have a different issue; which is that your keys aren't doing what you expect them? Can you post the output from running: lshal -m when pressing the Up, Down and Mute volume keys and stick that in a new bug report along with

[Bug 42886] Re: ibm-acpi volume control unpredictable

2006-05-11 Thread Martin Emrich
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 39098 *** Hi! output of lshal -m : [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~$ lshal -m Start monitoring devicelist: - pressing down computer_logicaldev_input condition ButtonPressed = volumedown computer_logicaldev_input condition