[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-14 Thread Martin
@Richard: I think I understand what Mathieu mean. At least, I see a case where it can be useful: imagine you want to reconfigure the box ip adress remotely. You may don't want it to be applied immediately, but for example at next reboot. So from my point of view, there should be a apply now AND

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-14 Thread Martin
Sorry, I was not 100% complete in the previous note: when you change to static and clic apply... for the first time in Live mode, *something* happen immediately which leads the box to be disconnected from the network. So new changes are not effectively applied. Then , While disconnected, the

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-14 Thread Martin
Based of the expected behavior described by Mathieu, there is still an issue within the Live mode of ubuntu (Live CD/USB). Basically , in this mode, changing from DHCP (default) to static and clic apply... effectively applies changes _immediatly_ (which is not expected base on Mathieu note).

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-13 Thread Martin
I can confirm this bug on a fresh ubuntu 10.04.4 (lucid). All you have to do to reproduce is installing, open network manager, set static ip adress and you'll see that you are disconnected (and never connected back on the new static IP). It means in clear, that if you need to change the ip

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-13 Thread Martin
What is important to notice is nothing more is happening in syslog when tweaking again network manager properties. The only way to get the new settings applied is: 1) right-clic on network applet, uncheck / check enable networking 2) unplug / plug the network cable. -- You received this bug

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-13 Thread Mathieu Trudel-Lapierre
The process is wrong. It's expected behavior that the settings don't change immediately; since you can change the settings to any connection, not just the active one, and nm-applet needs to speak to NM to change the settings. What you'll want to do is edit the connection settings, then click on

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-13 Thread Mathieu Trudel-Lapierre
Well, actually won't fix in this case because the title is should change immediately, which is explicitly what I describe above as something we don't want to do. ** Changed in: network-manager (Ubuntu) Status: Confirmed = Won't Fix -- You received this bug notification because you are a

[Desktop-packages] [Bug 297745] Re: Changing the IP address in NetworkManager should immediately change the IP on the interface

2012-03-13 Thread Richard Laager
Who expects this behavior? I would expect that when I'm editing the active connection, the changes are applied immediately. That fact that I can edit inactive connections is not relevant to how it should behave when I'm editing an active connection. -- You received this bug notification because