Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-31 Thread Clebert Suconic
You should probably raise an example on where it fails. Someone may take a look. Why don’t you start over with a question on user forums. With an example. If confirmed a bug open a JIRA. Open source projects are maintained by the community. As of now I have seen most of the NMS contributions

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-31 Thread dbeavon
Thanks for all the helpful information. I'm fairly new to using open-source projects so it was hard for me to phrase the right questions (ie questions without all the subtle and unintentional references to specific vendors, and the jboss issue-tracking site). I guess that the thing which I was

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-27 Thread Clebert Suconic
When companies offer support they do at their own discretion. Here in apache we develop software while we provide you the apache license with apache terms and its limited warranty. (Read the license for more information) On your case you are asking about why Red Hat is not offering support.

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-27 Thread Justin Bertram
> Is Apache Artemis supposed to be allowing connectivity from NMS-openwire clients? I'm not aware of any specific testing done with NMS clients using the OpenWire provider and Artemis, but since Artemis supports OpenWire I would generally expect such clients to work. > The following lists a

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-27 Thread Ragnar Paulson
As part of the NMS.AMQP project I can assure you that there is no intent to replace any transport other than AMQP. The NMS API is a general .NET API modeled after JMS. It can support a variety of transports (wireline implementations), one of which is selected when you instantiate an instance via

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-27 Thread Clebert Suconic
JBoss AMQ 7 is product from RedHat. You should ask Red Hat about it. On Fri, Aug 24, 2018 at 10:51 AM dbeavon wrote: > Can someone please clear up some confusion for me about NMS on Jboss AMQ 7 > (Artemis)? > > I am confused about why it has been "deprecated". The Jboss AMQ release > notes

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-27 Thread dbeavon
The bugs I was encountering while connecting from NMS clients were exposed as error messages in the broker logs. They appeared to be Artemis bugs. This doesn't have to be a redhat-specific question. I can rephrase if you like. Is Apache Artemis supposed to be allowing connectivity from

Re: Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-24 Thread Justin Bertram
It seems to me that you're asking for an explanation about Red Hat's official support policies on the ActiveMQ community developer's mailing list which isn't the right place for such a discussion. If you want to know more about Red Hat's policies you should engage them directly. As I see it,

Why the push to deprecate NMS-openwire?

2018-08-24 Thread dbeavon
Can someone please clear up some confusion for me about NMS on Jboss AMQ 7 (Artemis)? I am confused about why it has been "deprecated". The Jboss AMQ release notes say that "NMS messaging APIs are deprecated in AMQ 7". About a year ago I had done some of my own testing and ran into trouble