Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

Thanks all. I am struggling with the missing buildscan reports when running jobs with containers. I believe it is a big disadvantage to use docker if the buildscan doesn't show up. I will keep updating my progress in this thread. In the meanwhile, any comments, suggestions and objections are still

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

+1 Great feature that should help with complicated error cases. > On 11 Sep 2018, at 03:39, Henning Rohde wrote: > > +1 Nice proposal. It will help eradicate some of the inflexibility and > frustrations with Jenkins. > > On Wed, Sep 5, 2018 at 2:30 PM Yifan Zou >

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

+1 Nice proposal. It will help eradicate some of the inflexibility and frustrations with Jenkins. On Wed, Sep 5, 2018 at 2:30 PM Yifan Zou wrote: > Thank you all for making comments on this and I apologize for the late > reply. > > To clarify the concerns of testing locally, it is still able to

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

Thank you all for making comments on this and I apologize for the late reply. To clarify the concerns of testing locally, it is still able to run tests without Docker. One of the purposes of this is to create an identical environment as we are running in Jenkins that would be helpful to reproduce

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

BIG +1, the previous work on having docker build images [1] had a similar goal (to have a reproducible build environment). But this is even better because we will guarantee the exact same environment in Jenkins as well as any further improvements. It is important to document the setup process as

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

Hi, That's interesting, however, it's really important to still be able to easily run test locally, without any VM/Docker required. It should be activated by profile or so. Regards JB On 27/08/2018 19:53, Yifan Zou wrote: > Hi, > > I have a proposal for creating a reproducible environment for

Re: [Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

Hi Yifan, Thanks for the proposal. I like the idea of unifying test environments via Docker. It would be great if we could still easily run tests without Docker. Best, Max On 27.08.18 19:53, Yifan Zou wrote: Hi, I have a proposal for creating a reproducible environment for Jenkins tests

[Proposal] Creating a reproducible environment for Beam Jenkins Tests

Hi, I have a proposal for creating a reproducible environment for Jenkins tests by using docker container. The thing is, the environment configurations on Beam Jenkins slaves are sometimes different from developer's machines. Test failures on Jenkins may not be easy to reproduce locally. Also, it