Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-29 Thread Danny Chan
Yes, +1 to handle it case by case with proper reminders. Rui Wang 于2020年10月30日周五 上午6:19写道: > >People who write to dev@ list and attach the stacktrace as an image don't > >really know if the list accepts images or not. > >Making images forbidden does not help to teach people to > >attach

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-29 Thread Rui Wang
>People who write to dev@ list and attach the stacktrace as an image don't >really know if the list accepts images or not. >Making images forbidden does not help to teach people to >attach stacktraces as text. I guess the way will be when we see those cases, we reply to ask to replace the image

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-29 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
To all who vote for "disallow images", Do you think it really helps if the images are forbidden? People who write to dev@ list and attach the stacktrace as an image don't really know if the list accepts images or not. Making images forbidden does not help to teach people to attach stacktraces as

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-29 Thread Alessandro Solimando
Hi all, +1 for text over images whenever possible (for the same reason, it's convenient to have it indexed by search engines). +0 for image support, I see the benefits but I am afraid we will see less and less text/stack traces. Best regards, Alessandro On Wed, 28 Oct 2020 at 01:13, Michael Mior

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-27 Thread Michael Mior
+1 in favouring text over images where possible, -0 to allowing images on the dev list. (If images aren't allowed, I think it would almost be preferable if such messages could be rejected to give the author a chance to revise.) -- Michael Mior mm...@apache.org Le mar. 27 oct. 2020 à 15:12,

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-27 Thread Stamatis Zampetakis
+1 in favoring text over screenshots. To what mentioned already, I would encourage people to attach binary files for profiling snapshots and heap dumps in addition to static screenshots when the size is not prohibitive. I find it very helpful to be able to navigate the snapshot/dump myself in

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-27 Thread Francis Chuang
I agree with Julian. Stacktraces should be posted in text as much as possible due to the ability for the traces to be indexed by search engines. I've often googled part of a stacktrace to find a solution to the problem I was encountering in a mailing list or on stackoverflow. Francis On

Re: [DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-27 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
We should enable images on dev list. They are helpful. That can be done by infra after the relevant vote passes. Vladimir

[DISCUSS] Screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions

2020-10-27 Thread Julian Hyde
There is a growing trend of attaching screenshots of stack traces, code, and debugger sessions to JIRA cases and email threads. I don't like it. I think we should have a policy discouraging screenshots. In my opinion, the text is almost always preferable. It can be found by search engines. It