Re: [DISCUSS] CASSANDRA-16767, CASSANDRA-16768, and CASSANDRA-16769 for 3.11.x

2021-08-10 Thread bened...@apache.org
Hi Scott, I wonder if it’s possible that too few people who saw your email consider themselves sufficiently involved in this part of the codebase. People tend to keep quiet about stuff they don’t participate in deeply, which is why I haven’t responded – and I wonder if this might explain the

Re: [DISCUSS] CASSANDRA-16840 - Close native transport port before hint transfer during decommission

2021-08-10 Thread Jeff Jirsa
The hint behavior aside, stopping native protocol once you begin a decom seems like something most people would benefit from, even if they dont realize that's what they want to happen. On Tue, Aug 10, 2021 at 12:53 PM Matt Fleming wrote: > Hi, > > With the way that hint transfer currently

[DISCUSS] CASSANDRA-16840 - Close native transport port before hint transfer during decommission

2021-08-10 Thread Matt Fleming
Hi, With the way that hint transfer currently works during decommission, it's possible to leave hints on the disk of the decommissioning node if those hints are generated after the decommission begins. I'd like to discuss automatically closing the native transport port before hints are