Re: Will 1.0.1 1.1 be incompatible with 1.0?

2006-01-20 Thread Paul McMahan
Another option would be to add a new attribute to deployment plans called something like isCompatibleWith or upgrades. This attribute would tell Geronimo that it can use this version of the component in place of the component that it upgrades. So for v1.0.1 we could use configuration

Re: Will 1.0.1 1.1 be incompatible with 1.0?

2006-01-20 Thread toby cabot
Aaron, Thanks for raising this issue - this is important. It's tacky to force people to change their plans for a minor version upgrade. 1) Ship 1.0.1 with all the configIds saying 1.0 so there is no issue for at least that release I like this option for this branch. It looks as if the plan

Will 1.0.1 1.1 be incompatible with 1.0?

2006-01-19 Thread Aaron Mulder
It seems like if we move ahead as planned for 1.0.1 and 1.1, we're going to ship a product with configIds like geronimo/j2ee-server/1.0.1/car, which means that many deployment plans written for 1.0 will not be able to be deployed unmodified on 1.0 -- and it will instantly turn a huge number of