Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-05 Thread Aaron Mulder
Hey, no worries. I don't have the spare cycles to work on the M2 migration myself, so whatever method you guys think is best, I'm all for it. I just wanted to make sure you're prepared for some pain down the road if you go the branch path, beacuse I think it will be nasty. If I were doing this

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-05 Thread Alan D. Cabrera
Jacek Laskowski wrote: On 7/5/06, Alan D. Cabrera <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm afraid that I have to agree w/ Aaron here Jacek. I'm not sure that there was a consensus on this. If discussion died down on this it was because it's the 4th of July. Ok, you *might* be right, but should I vote

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-05 Thread Jacek Laskowski
On 7/5/06, Alan D. Cabrera <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm afraid that I have to agree w/ Aaron here Jacek. I'm not sure that there was a consensus on this. If discussion died down on this it was because it's the 4th of July. Ok, you *might* be right, but should I vote for creating a branch f

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-05 Thread Alan D. Cabrera
Jacek Laskowski wrote: On 7/4/06, Aaron Mulder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: When discussing whether a branch was appropriate, I expressed a concern that it would be difficult to merge changes from this branch to HEAD because SVN seems to have difficulty handling multiple revisions of add/delete/m

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Jacek Laskowski
On 7/4/06, Aaron Mulder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: When discussing whether a branch was appropriate, I expressed a concern that it would be difficult to merge changes from this branch to HEAD because SVN seems to have difficulty handling multiple revisions of add/delete/move/copy operations in a

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread John Sisson
Jason, INAL, but sections 10 B-E in their open source contract don't sound appropriate for ASF use to me. http://www.perforce.com/perforce/contracts/open_source.pdf We wouldn't want the situation where we have to uninstall it or Apache and the development community has to start paying for it

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Jason Dillon
On Jul 4, 2006, at 4:21 AM, Aaron Mulder wrote: Are you recommending that the project switch to Perforce, or is this just wishful thinking? Well... both I guess. But given our reality its more of the later. Also, one more note on the merging -- If we change the directory layout in the branc

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Matt Hogstrom
Sent a note in a related thread asking to have RTC suspended for this activity and let the work proceed in trunk directly. Aaron Mulder wrote: Are you recommending that the project switch to Perforce, or is this just wishful thinking? Also, one more note on the merging -- If we change the dire

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
Are you recommending that the project switch to Perforce, or is this just wishful thinking? Also, one more note on the merging -- If we change the directory layout in the branch, it will be very hard to merge any patches to HEAD into the branch to keep them in sync since all the patch paths will

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Jason Dillon
FYI... Perforce may be commercial, but they provide free licenses for qualifying open source usage: http://perforce.com/perforce/opensource-faq.html :-) --jason On Jul 4, 2006, at 3:50 AM, Aaron Mulder wrote: Jacek, When discussing whether a branch was appropriate, I expressed a conc

Re: m2migration branch is available

2006-07-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
Jacek, When discussing whether a branch was appropriate, I expressed a concern that it would be difficult to merge changes from this branch to HEAD because SVN seems to have difficulty handling multiple revisions of add/delete/move/copy operations in a single merge (and I understand the M2 restru

m2migration branch is available

2006-07-03 Thread Jacek Laskowski
Hi, Just created a branch - m2migration - for all our work pertaining to the M2 migration of Geronimo build. Everybody's welcome to work on it *without* RTC on. Revolutionary rules are enabled again! ;-) The branch is available at https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/geronimo/branches/m2migration.