Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jules Gosnell
David Jencks wrote: It is possible (I think) to do what you want, but I do not recommend it. I would prefer that you use external plans, and write 2 new modules inside configs, to deploy your sample to jetty and to tomcat. Take the geronimo-web.xml out of the app and put it in src/

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jules Gosnell
Aaron Mulder wrote: Well... is it possible to make this not specific to WADI? Perhaps make it a generic clustering manager tag, and is just so happens that the only classes we let you configure so far are the WADI ones? Ideally, we'd put some generic interface in the Geronimo space, and

Re: [wadi-dev] Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jules Gosnell
After further thought... I imagine it going like this: container checks for the WEB-INF/web.xml/distributable/ tag. If it exists, container looks at the e.g. geronimo-web.xml/distributable-session-manager/ tag. The value of this tag could be either an enum (e.g. {WADI,...}), a classname or

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Greg Wilkins
Aaron Mulder wrote: Well... is it possible to make this not specific to WADI? Perhaps make it a generic clustering manager tag, and is just so happens that the only classes we let you configure so far are the WADI ones? Ideally, we'd put some generic interface in the Geronimo space, and

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jules Gosnell
Greg Wilkins wrote: Aaron Mulder wrote: Well... is it possible to make this not specific to WADI? Perhaps make it a generic clustering manager tag, and is just so happens that the only classes we let you configure so far are the WADI ones? Ideally, we'd put some generic interface in the

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jeff Genender
Greg Wilkins wrote: Aaron Mulder wrote: Well... is it possible to make this not specific to WADI? Perhaps make it a generic clustering manager tag, and is just so happens that the only classes we let you configure so far are the WADI ones? Ideally, we'd put some generic interface in the

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Aaron Mulder
In my personal experience, any machine in a cluster is fully in a cluster -- I haven't seen something like 10 machines running 1 clustered app and then each running something else on the side. However, it is kind of nice in WebLogic that you can deploy to either a cluster or a single machine. I

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-05 Thread Jeff Genender
Aaron Mulder wrote: In my personal experience, any machine in a cluster is fully in a cluster -- I haven't seen something like 10 machines running 1 clustered app and then each running something else on the side. I can't agree...I may want to cluster my app, but I surely do not want to

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-04 Thread Jules Gosnell
Aaron, David, or anyone in the know :-) Maybe you can help me with this: I have a WADI demo webapp. To get it running with Jetty, I need a WEB-INF/geronimo-web.xml that looks like this: web-app xmlns=http://geronimo.apache.org/xml/ns/j2ee/web/jetty-1.0; configId=wadi

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-04 Thread David Jencks
It is possible (I think) to do what you want, but I do not recommend it. I would prefer that you use external plans, and write 2 new modules inside configs, to deploy your sample to jetty and to tomcat. Take the geronimo-web.xml out of the app and put it in src/ plan/plan.xml. However,

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
Yeah, I was going to say, let's merge the manager and session-manager elements from the 2 separate plans into a single session-manager element in the geronimo-web plan. Though it looks like one takes a class name and the other takes a GBean name, so we'd have to figure that out. I assume that

Re: geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2006-01-04 Thread Aaron Mulder
Well... is it possible to make this not specific to WADI? Perhaps make it a generic clustering manager tag, and is just so happens that the only classes we let you configure so far are the WADI ones? Ideally, we'd put some generic interface in the Geronimo space, and then the WADI ones would

geronimo-web.xml, container-config, container-specific namespaces

2005-10-30 Thread Aaron Mulder
David J, I thought when you added the separate Tomcat and Jetty namespaces, you were going to remove the container-config section from the generic geronimo-web.xml, but it seems that it's still there. Jeff thinks maybe it's for something like the console, where we want it to work in both Tomcat