Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-13 Thread Andrew Purtell
We are at 70 issues resolved for 2.5.11. There are two issues pending, related to tweaking precommit testing given a recent reduction in available resources. As soon as those are settled we can release. https://issues.apache.org/jira/projects/HBASE/versions/12354955

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-10 Thread Andrew Purtell
 We could further restrict branch-2/2.5/2.6 precommits to testing only Hadoop 3 and JDK 8 plus whichever later JDK we consider the leading edge. My understanding is that is currently 17. That would reduce that workload by 50%? We could even drop JDK 8 in precommits for further savings. The peri

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Istvan Toth
The currently expected workflow is to do a separate PR for branch-2 to run the tests there, but then the patches are usually just manually backported to 2.5 and 2.6 without further CI tests, based on the committer's judgement. On Fri, Jan 10, 2025 at 6:44 AM Istvan Toth wrote: > I'm afraid that

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Istvan Toth
I'm afraid that wouldn't be enough. branch-2.x tests are one of the main causes of overload, as they currently consume thrice the resources (JDK and Hadoop combinations) of branch-3 and master, where we only test for JDK17+Hadoop3. I've suggested some more heavy-handed changes in a new DISCUSS thr

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Andrew Purtell
Should we limit precommit for the time being to just master and branch-2.5 and branch-2.6, given master-first commit policy and the ultimate goal of most changes to get them into the GA releases? The rest are in pre-alpha or beta state. I’m going to pursue a targeted donation to improve resource

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Nick Dimiduk
We lost a fair number of build workers at the end of the year. It now looks like our builds are back-logged significantly. Your build failed due to timeout waiting for a build worker to make itself available. https://ci-hbase.apache.org/label/hbase/load-statistics On Thu, Jan 9, 2025 at 5:33 PM D

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Nihal Jain
Thank you Andrew for the heads up. HBASE-29028 is merged. We will hold on HBASE-28832 and HBASE-28983 and take these post release. On 2025/01/09 11:30:19 Istvan Toth wrote: > Thank you. > I've merged the patches, and will update Docs ASAP. > > Istvan > > On Thu, Jan 9, 2025 at 12:27 PM Nick Dim

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Istvan Toth
Thank you. I've merged the patches, and will update Docs ASAP. Istvan On Thu, Jan 9, 2025 at 12:27 PM Nick Dimiduk wrote: > Okay, let's go for it, István. This will be our policy for active > release lines going forward. Go ahead with your patches and please > update the compatibility guideline

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-09 Thread Nick Dimiduk
Okay, let's go for it, István. This will be our policy for active release lines going forward. Go ahead with your patches and please update the compatibility guidelines in the book relating to supported Hadoop versions and CVE mitigation, as appropriate. Thanks, Nick On Thu, Jan 9, 2025 at 7:57 A

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-08 Thread Andrew Purtell
I have not been following. I’ve been away for a while and am getting back up to speed. Thanks for summarizing the discussion so far. I support it too. For purely practical reasons, I admit. We have to be CVE clean, to the extent possible, with annoying documentation requirements when known iss

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-08 Thread Istvan Toth
We've updated the default Hadoop version on the non-release branches to 3.4.1, and have discussed doing the same on the release branches. I don't know if you've been following the discussion threads about this Andrew, but it basically a dilemma of * risking undetected problems on HBase patch relea

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-07 Thread Andrew Purtell
Hi Nihal, I think we could take HBASE-29028 and HBASE-28983 in the upcoming release right now. Let me follow up on the respective PRs. For HBASE-28832, I think it should have some time to bake. Maybe in branch-2 first, for kicking the tires, and then we could backport it to the releases. On Mon,

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-06 Thread Nihal Jain
Hi, Dávid Paksy is working on backporting changes for upgrading to bootstrap 5.3.3. Following PRs are pending for this: 1) HBASE-29028 Backport missing UI patches to branch-2.5 2) HBASE-28832 Upgrade from bootstrap 3.4.1 to non vulnerable version 5.3.3 3) HBASE-28983 Static resources are not load

Re: Time for 2.5.11

2025-01-06 Thread Andrew Purtell
Related to 2.5.11, there are 61 resolved issues*, and one pending that may land in the next couple of days. * - https://issues.apache.org/jira/projects/HBASE/versions/12354955 On Mon, Jan 6, 2025 at 9:37 AM Andrew Purtell wrote: > We are overdue for a maintenance release of 2.5. > > If you have