Re: Proposal: Streamlet Custom Operator

2018-09-27 Thread Karthik Ramasamy
Thanks Ning - Nice proposal and looks good for me.

On Thu, Sep 27, 2018 at 11:25 AM Ning Wang  wrote:

> Hi,
>
> I was trying to add the support to reuse existing Bolts in the Streamlet
> API last week and got some feedbacks about the feature and the
> improvements. After reconsidering what I want to have, I think it can be
> generalized a bit to "Custom Operator".
>
> Here is a design doc to summerize what in my mind and what I am planning to
> do. Please feel free to comment:
>
> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XzF0IlfuaaW8Gx3cPx1xLtP-kgCFK0TRNS5aAzuMuMg/edit#
> .
> All ideas are welcome.
>
> Thanks in advance!
>


Re: [VOTE] Heron Release 0.20.0-incubating Candidate 4

2018-09-27 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi,

Dave asked me to take a look and I think the LICENSE and NOTICE file need a bit 
more work. I would probably vote -1 on this release if it come up on the IPMC 
and I reviewed it.

Here a list of (permissive) software that is bundled in the source release but 
is not mentioned in LICENSE:
glyphicons-halflings-regular.svg
d3-tip.min.0.6.3.js
d3.min.3.4.11.js
html5-trunk.js
jquery-ui-1.8.23.custom.min.js
list.min.1.1.1.js
moment.min.2.8.3.js
underscore-min.1.6.0.js
third_party/kashmir/*
third_party/libunwind/libunwind-1.1-cache.patch
third_party/python/cpplint/cpplint.py
normalize.css 
JSXTransformer.0.10.0.js (also included node.js, browser.js and a number if 
other pieces of code all under different licenses and owners)
javadoc.bzl
build_defs.bzl
autogen.sh
jarjar_rules.bzl
maven-pom-version.sh (and other files)
base_spout.py (and other files)
generate-zookeeper-config.sh
gtest.BUILD
cloudpickle.py (which may also incorrectly have an ASF header, not multiple 
copyright notices/licenses)

I’ve not checked if that any ALv2 bundled bits have NOTICE files, which could 
have an impact on your NOTICE file.

I can see jQuery is listed twice under two different licenses is that correct?

There some files incorrectly with "Copyright 2015 The Heron Authors.” in their 
headers.

Thanks,
Justin

P.S I’m not subscribed to your list so please CC me if you have any questions.

Proposal: Streamlet Custom Operator

2018-09-27 Thread Ning Wang
Hi,

I was trying to add the support to reuse existing Bolts in the Streamlet
API last week and got some feedbacks about the feature and the
improvements. After reconsidering what I want to have, I think it can be
generalized a bit to "Custom Operator".

Here is a design doc to summerize what in my mind and what I am planning to
do. Please feel free to comment:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XzF0IlfuaaW8Gx3cPx1xLtP-kgCFK0TRNS5aAzuMuMg/edit#.
All ideas are welcome.

Thanks in advance!