[CANCEL] [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

I will create new artifacts and restart the vote once HIVE-23215 is committed. -Jesús On Tue, Apr 7, 2020 at 9:26 PM Jesus Camacho Rodriguez wrote: > > The release -1 votes aren't vetos. You just need more +1's than -1's. > Thanks, I had not checked the bylaws and remembered this incorrectly

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

> The release -1 votes aren't vetos. You just need more +1's than -1's. Thanks, I had not checked the bylaws and remembered this incorrectly :( -Jesús On Tue, Apr 7, 2020 at 1:42 PM Owen O'Malley wrote: > Sorry Jesus for not getting back to you sooner. I started diving into > ORC-577, but

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

Sorry Jesus for not getting back to you sooner. I started diving into ORC-577, but didn't finish. The release -1 votes aren't vetos. You just need more +1's than -1's. https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/Hive/Bylaws#Bylaws-Voting That said, I'd ask for a different approach. Maybe we

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

@Owen, will you be able to provide feedback on HIVE-22959 / ORC-577 shortly? The -1 constitutes a veto to the release, but it has been a week since we received that vote and we are still awaiting feedback. Currently the storage-api release and rest of Panos contribution are on hold because of

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

+1 built and ran few tests locally. On Mon, Mar 30, 2020 at 2:21 PM Owen O'Malley wrote: > In evaluating this RC, I discovered HIVE-22959, which is the only patch in > this RC. > > I'm uncomfortable with the API added by HIVE-22959, because it is > duplicating a lot of the functionality from

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

In evaluating this RC, I discovered HIVE-22959, which is the only patch in this RC. I'm uncomfortable with the API added by HIVE-22959, because it is duplicating a lot of the functionality from VectorizedRowBatch. I'll look at the motivating ORC-577 tomorrow, but for now I'm -1 on releasing it.

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

+1. Verified the signature, checksum and build. Vineet > On Mar 30, 2020, at 1:20 AM, Zoltan Haindrich wrote: > > +1 > > * verified checksum/etc > * built and run tests locally > * built orc/master against it > * there doesn't seem to be a staged nexus repo for this - but it seems like >

Re: [VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

+1 * verified checksum/etc * built and run tests locally * built orc/master against it * there doesn't seem to be a staged nexus repo for this - but it seems like earlier releases also doesn't had that; meanwhile https://repo.maven.apache.org/maven2/org/apache/hive/hive-storage-api/2.7.1/ seems

[VOTE] Should we release Hive Storage API 2.7.2-rc0?

All, I'd like to make a storage-api release with HIVE-22959 in it. Should we release the following artifacts as Hive Storage API 2.7.2? tar: http://home.apache.org/~jcamacho/hive-storage-2.7.2/ tag: