Re: what to expect from fcgid
It is very interesting. Especially if it is possible to associate FastCgi servers(socket) with apache handlers and then use handlers where needed as SetHandler/AddHandler. Also i'm glad to hear that mod_extfcgi will not cross mod_fcgid functionality. I can try it on development server (FreeBSD). But my skill may be not enough to compile it. On 2/21/2014 6:56 PM, Антон Панков wrote: Dear All. Please, explain what functionality now in trunk and what plans for mod_fcgid. I miss FastCGIExternalServer feature. I am in the final stages of testing a new FastCGI module, written for 2.4 (although it MAY work on 2.2) called mod_extfcgi. It *only* deals with external FastCGI application, it has absolutely no process management, as that is best left to dedicated code for that purpose. It supports both TCP and UNIX sockets, it does authn and authz and, unlike any other FastCGI module Ive seen so far, it supports the FastCGI FILTER role. I also think it's fairly easy to configure but then, I would :) I want to do some more testing and clean up the documentation before I publish it on github but I should get that done during the course of the next week if you want to play with it when it's done. Hope that helps. Kean PS in the interestes of full disclosure this is my first Apache module so there may well be some rough edges, I am eagery looking forward to more expert eyes critiqueing it. -- С уважением, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru
Re: what to expect from fcgid
https://github.com/hollow/mod_fastcgi_handler is quite easy to configure, unfortunetly it is abandoned 2014-02-21 17:56 GMT+01:00 Антон Панков ant_m...@inbox.ru: Dear All. Please, explain what functionality now in trunk and what plans for mod_fcgid. I miss FastCGIExternalServer feature. The problem is to allow different site parts to be processed by different FastCGI servers (frankly speaking, by different php-fpm pools). Also,thereisa need of external access checker. This type of configuration has the following problem with apache 2.4.X: 1. With mod_fastcgi and some magic [1] it is possible to achieve desired configuration. But mod_fastcgi doesn't compile with Apache 2.4. 2. Mod_fcgid lack of FastCGIExternalServer feature. 3. Mod_proxy_fcgi has rough configuration. It can't be tied to handlers, so it assigned to directory, not to specified files. Also, it avoid unix sockets (i know, they are in trunk), So, the question is whether things that will help me already in trunk? Does it make sense to wait for future apache httpd release? May be i do things wrong and somebody can direct me to right way . Appendices 1. Magic to run different #- PHP startup as unpriveleged user (general purpose script)- #-php-fpm (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm standart pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-wxsf -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common # PHP regular fastcgi starter Action php-fc /internal/doscript Alias /internal/doscript /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm #-BOX realm --- #Accesschecker for BOX realm FastCgiServer /usr/fdsys/acheckers/boxcheck.pl -processes 2 #PHP startup as boxscript user #-php-fpm-box (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm boxscript pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-box # PHP magic for Box starter Action php-fc-box /internal/doscript-box Alias /internal/doscript-box /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -- Best regards, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru
Re: what to expect from fcgid
https://github.com/hollow/mod_fastcgi_handler Yes, this kind of configuration is what i want. I think this link usefull for Kean Johnston, who is gathering to please us with mod_extfcgi. https://github.com/hollow/mod_fastcgi_handler is quite easy to configure, unfortunetly it is abandoned 2014-02-21 17:56 GMT+01:00 Антон Панков ant_m...@inbox.ru: Dear All. Please, explain what functionality now in trunk and what plans for mod_fcgid. I miss FastCGIExternalServer feature. The problem is to allow different site parts to be processed by different FastCGI servers (frankly speaking, by different php-fpm pools). Also,thereisa need of external access checker. This type of configuration has the following problem with apache 2.4.X: 1. With mod_fastcgi and some magic [1] it is possible to achieve desired configuration. But mod_fastcgi doesn't compile with Apache 2.4. 2. Mod_fcgid lack of FastCGIExternalServer feature. 3. Mod_proxy_fcgi has rough configuration. It can't be tied to handlers, so it assigned to directory, not to specified files. Also, it avoid unix sockets (i know, they are in trunk), So, the question is whether things that will help me already in trunk? Does it make sense to wait for future apache httpd release? May be i do things wrong and somebody can direct me to right way . Appendices 1. Magic to run different #- PHP startup as unpriveleged user (general purpose script)- #-php-fpm (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm standart pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-wxsf -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common # PHP regular fastcgi starter Action php-fc /internal/doscript Alias /internal/doscript /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm #-BOX realm --- #Accesschecker for BOX realm FastCgiServer /usr/fdsys/acheckers/boxcheck.pl -processes 2 #PHP startup as boxscript user #-php-fpm-box (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm boxscript pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-box # PHP magic for Box starter Action php-fc-box /internal/doscript-box Alias /internal/doscript-box /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -- Best regards, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru -- С уважением, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru
Re: what to expect from fcgid
On 2/24/2014 1:23 PM, Anthony Pankov wrote: It is very interesting. Especially if it is possible to associate FastCgi servers(socket) with apache handlers and then use handlers where needed as SetHandler/AddHandler. Yes you can indeed do that. Also i'm glad to hear that mod_extfcgi will not cross mod_fcgid functionality. That is very much by design. I want it to *only* deal with FastCGI, not to bolt on a process manager as well. I have always felt the process management for the FastCGI application servers were best left to outside of the Apache core, if for no other reason that it is common for people to have mixed nginx/Apache setups and both should be able to use the FastCGI applications. Also, to be honest, a huge percentage of people that want FastCGI will be using it for PHP, and php-fpm does its own process management. Kean
what to expect from fcgid
Dear All. Please, explain what functionality now in trunk and what plans for mod_fcgid. I miss FastCGIExternalServer feature. The problem is to allow different site parts to be processed by different FastCGI servers (frankly speaking, by different php-fpm pools). Also,thereisa need of external access checker. This type of configuration has the following problem with apache 2.4.X: 1. With mod_fastcgi and some magic [1] it is possible to achieve desired configuration. But mod_fastcgi doesn't compile with Apache 2.4. 2. Mod_fcgid lack of FastCGIExternalServer feature. 3. Mod_proxy_fcgi has rough configuration. It can't be tied to handlers, so it assigned to directory, not to specified files. Also, it avoid unix sockets (i know, they are in trunk), So, the question is whether things that will help me already in trunk? Does it make sense to wait for future apache httpd release? May be i do things wrong and somebody can direct me to right way . Appendices 1. Magic to run different #- PHP startup as unpriveleged user (general purpose script)- #-php-fpm (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm standart pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-wxsf -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-common # PHP regular fastcgi starter Action php-fc /internal/doscript Alias /internal/doscript /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm #-BOX realm --- #Accesschecker for BOX realm FastCgiServer /usr/fdsys/acheckers/boxcheck.pl -processes 2 #PHP startup as boxscript user #-php-fpm-box (emptyfile) treat as a pipe to php-fpm boxscript pool FastCgiExternalServer /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -socket /var/run/fastcgi/php-fpm-box # PHP magic for Box starter Action php-fc-box /internal/doscript-box Alias /internal/doscript-box /var/fdwww/outroot/php-fpm-box -- Best regards, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru
mod_fastcgi and Apache 2.4 (Re: what to expect from fcgid)
On 21.02.2014 11:56, ? ?? wrote: But mod_fastcgi doesn't compile with Apache 2.4. This is entirely possible, actually -- and has been for a while. Pathes exist and are maintained: https://github.com/ByteInternet/libapache-mod-fastcgi Yours, -mi
Re: mod_fastcgi and Apache 2.4 (Re: what to expect from fcgid)
Thank you for suggestion. But this packet does not install from box in FreeBSD. It does not install via apxs -cia also. Besides that there is a patch for mod_fastcgi in FreeBSD ports that doesn't seem trivial. On 21.02.2014 11:56, Антон Панков wrote: But mod_fastcgi doesn't compile with Apache 2.4. This is entirely possible, actually -- and has been for a while. Pathes exist and are maintained: https://github.com/ByteInternet/libapache-mod-fastcgi Yours, -mi -- С уважением, Anthony mailto:ant_m...@inbox.ru
Re: mod_fastcgi and Apache 2.4 (Re: what to expect from fcgid)
On 21.02.2014 13:59, Anthony Pankov wrote: Thank you for suggestion. But this packet does not install from box in FreeBSD. It does not install via apxs -cia also. Besides that there is a patch for mod_fastcgi in FreeBSD ports that doesn't seem trivial. Unless apa...@freebsd.org team comes up with a good reason to the contrary, the mod_fastcgi port will be buildable with either 2.2 or 2.4 apache in a week or so -- the PR addressing the problem was submitted last summer. http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=ports/179710 Meanwhile, you can test the update offered on the above ticket (second diff). Barring show-stopping feedback, that's what will be committed to the port. For more FreeBSD-specific questions about Apache, please contact apa...@freebsd.org (and/or myself) -- not this list. Yours, -mi
Re: what to expect from fcgid
On 2/21/2014 6:56 PM, Антон Панков wrote: Dear All. Please, explain what functionality now in trunk and what plans for mod_fcgid. I miss FastCGIExternalServer feature. I am in the final stages of testing a new FastCGI module, written for 2.4 (although it MAY work on 2.2) called mod_extfcgi. It *only* deals with external FastCGI application, it has absolutely no process management, as that is best left to dedicated code for that purpose. It supports both TCP and UNIX sockets, it does authn and authz and, unlike any other FastCGI module Ive seen so far, it supports the FastCGI FILTER role. I also think it's fairly easy to configure but then, I would :) I want to do some more testing and clean up the documentation before I publish it on github but I should get that done during the course of the next week if you want to play with it when it's done. Hope that helps. Kean PS in the interestes of full disclosure this is my first Apache module so there may well be some rough edges, I am eagery looking forward to more expert eyes critiqueing it.
