Re: Re : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit: r685401 - /mina/trunk/core/pom.xml

2008-08-18 Thread Niall Pemberton
On Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 12:04 AM, Emmanuel Lecharny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Edouard De Oliveira wrote: snip/ I know that having a core that do not rely on some other lib is a good feature. But is code dup worth it ? I personnaly hate it but i'm not saying we absolutely should avoid it

Re: Re : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit: r685401 - /mina/trunk/core/pom.xml

2008-08-14 Thread Julien Vermillard
On Thu, 14 Aug 2008 01:04:02 +0200 Emmanuel Lecharny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Edouard De Oliveira wrote: snip/ I know that having a core that do not rely on some other lib is a good feature. But is code dup worth it ? I personnaly hate it but i'm not saying we absolutely should avoid it

Re: Re : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit: r685401 - /mina/trunk/core/pom.xml

2008-08-14 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
Julien Vermillard wrote: snip/ More seriously, minimising core dependencies is important, I know you all use maven and don't care, but a full lib for a 200 LoC class it's a bit ridiculous for me, but if it's used in critical code, and we deeply need update and fixes, why not. I would also

Re : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit: r685401 - /mina/trunk/core/pom.xml

2008-08-13 Thread Edouard De Oliveira
with them my 2 cents :)  Cordialement, Regards, -Edouard De Oliveira- http://tedorg.free.fr/en/main.php - Message d'origine De : Julien Vermillard [EMAIL PROTECTED] À : dev@mina.apache.org Envoyé le : Mercredi, 13 Août 2008, 12h26mn 16s Objet : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit

Re: Re : Commons Codec Base64 Was : Re: Re : svn commit: r685401 - /mina/trunk/core/pom.xml

2008-08-13 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
Edouard De Oliveira wrote: snip/ I know that having a core that do not rely on some other lib is a good feature. But is code dup worth it ? I personnaly hate it but i'm not saying we absolutely should avoid it specially when we're talking about only one class ... Well, we have to balance