I will not be continuing this discussion. I will leave it to others to pick
it up if they feel it's needed.
--
View this message in context:
http://apache-nifi-developer-list.39713.n7.nabble.com/MiNiFi-C-Data-Provenance-and-Related-Issues-tp14024p14058.html
Sent from the Apache NiFi Developer
"Yes but there can be other hubs too and in parallel."
[Daniel]For MiNiFi C++ -> SystemA -> SystemB -> ... -> NiFi, if you dont
want provenance to travel then I don't see it as an issue since the outgoing
message would be identical to what you have now. If you feel it's going to
be extremely
As to Joe and Aldrin's concerns, I feel a bit more detail of what I had in
mind might clear up some of the concerns and vagaries (all valid) that you
mentioned.
As Aldrin mentioned, to me provenance is not about metadata needed for
routing. I don't doubt there are use cases for that, as Randy
Since MiNiFi C++ requires completely new code (unlike the Java version), I
don't see any reason we cant deviate where it makes requirement sense. If
we move the provenance onto the flowfile, then your build issues and my
stability issues can be simplified because the local provenance repo becomes
This is a break off from the discussion on the MiNiFi C++ 0.1.0 Release
thread. I assume a hub and spoke NiFi/MiNiFi C++ architecture.
As discussed on that thread, I am concerned about the existing choice for
data provenance tracking and the implications it leads to as well as the
current data
For me personally, I don't see a value add of MiNiFi Java. The needs that
NiFi can't address MiNiFi Java can't either, so my focus is MiNiFi C++ as
that is the hole that needs fixing, again in my opinion, so that is where my
MiNiFi focus is going to be.
As I go through things I am sure I will
Having been out of touch since MiNiFi C++ got added and just getting into it,
is there a reason the C++ version is trying to follow closely the MiNiFi
Java version rather than just insuring connectivity with NiFi? I have not
been able to find alot of details regarding the roadmap for MiNiFi C++.
