Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-24 Thread Niels Basjes
To me this sounds like an excellent idea. A while ago I wrote some processors I wanted to use in conjunction with MiNiFi and as a consequence they needed to be built against NiFi 1.7. See https://dsmr.basjes.nl/#apache-minifi-processors With this transition I expect (like to have) the versions of

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-22 Thread Matt Burgess
Andy is correct, I should have been more specific in referring to MiNiFi strictly as "MiNiFi Java" for this discussion. MiNiFi C++ would remain its own repo with its own build processes, release cadence, etc. On Thu, May 21, 2020 at 3:59 PM Andy LoPresto wrote: > > Jeff, my understanding is that

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-21 Thread Andy LoPresto
Jeff, my understanding is that MiNiFi C++ development will continue unaffected by this. While the release process may shift slightly as MiNiFi Java and NiFi are combined, I actually think this will improve both processes and shouldn’t negatively influence the capability to release either in a

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-21 Thread Jeff Zemerick
Apologies if this has been discussed previously. I've not kept up on the Mi/NiFi progress as much lately. When I think of two projects being combined I usually consider the connection between the lifecycles of the two projects. One thing I always liked about MiNiFi being separate was its ability

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-21 Thread Joe Witt
Yes please! On Thu, May 21, 2020 at 1:53 PM Andy LoPresto wrote: > Matt, > > I think this is a great idea, and I think it could also provide a bridge > to the reduced kernel build of NiFi with separate extensions that the > extensions registry will ultimately offer. Once the MiNiFi and NiFi >

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-21 Thread Andy LoPresto
Matt, I think this is a great idea, and I think it could also provide a bridge to the reduced kernel build of NiFi with separate extensions that the extensions registry will ultimately offer. Once the MiNiFi and NiFi assemblies are complete, it should be possible to add a third which does

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing MiNiFi into NiFi

2020-05-21 Thread Pierre Villard
Nothing useful to add other than I know this is going to be a lot of work, but this is GREAT! Thanks, Pierre Le jeu. 21 mai 2020 à 19:44, Matt Burgess a écrit : > All, > > I'm currently working on MINIFI-422, which aims to bring the MiNiFi > code into the NiFi codebase and have the MiNiFi