[DISCUSS] graduation from the incubator

2019-03-15 Thread David P Grove
I'd like to kick off a discussion to assess the project's readiness for graduation from the incubator. Per Rodric's recent stats [1], the community has developed nicely in terms of code contribution. We've released a number of software components following the Apache release process. We are

Re: Welcome Krzysztof Sobkowiak as an additional incubation mentor!

2019-03-15 Thread Sobkowiak Krzysztof
Hi Thanks for the warm welcome :)  I'm glad to be part of your community and I'll do my best to help you on the way to be TLP Best regards Krzysztof On 14.03.2019 15:05, Matt Rutkowski wrote: Welcome Krzysztof! Appreciate the great support from all our mentors as we indeed complete the

Re: OpenWhisk Apps on Knative

2019-03-15 Thread Carlos Santana
Matt Priti I see the PR got merged/closed with no discussion Here is my initial feedback: I wasted like 30 minutes looking for the hello.js openwhisk action and how this was used to build final docker image to be use in knative. Never found it, after reading every file I think I finally realize

Re: [DISCUSS] release openwhisk CLI

2019-03-15 Thread Carlos Santana
+1 Yay!! On Fri, Mar 15, 2019 at 9:31 AM Dave Grove wrote: > > > On 2019/02/21 17:29:40, Rodric Rabbah wrote: > > I have reviewed the the CLI related repos listed below and think we > should > > delay release of the CLI until the following PRs/issues are addressed. > > The pending PRs have all

Re: override main on activation?

2019-03-15 Thread Carlos Santana
I'm guessing you already tried passing the name of the function as parameter and got "is not a function" :-) function man(param) { param["main"](param) } At least for me I consider best practice to users to avoid packaging into a single file/zip multiple functions I think OpenWhisk gave a good

Re: [DISCUSS] release openwhisk CLI

2019-03-15 Thread Dave Grove
On 2019/02/21 17:29:40, Rodric Rabbah wrote: > I have reviewed the the CLI related repos listed below and think we should > delay release of the CLI until the following PRs/issues are addressed. The pending PRs have all been merged and I believe we are finally ready to go ahead with

Re: OpenWhisk Apps on Knative

2019-03-15 Thread James Thomas
My 2 cents (from a personal perspective - these views are my own and not my employers yada yada)... Despite the marketing hype, (at the moment) knative isn't a serverless platform like openwhisk. It's a Containers-as-a-Service platform (which scales from zero) than a Functions-as-a-Service

Re: override main on activation?

2019-03-15 Thread James Thomas
This is an interesting idea. Lambda has a nice feature of being able to create functions from an S3 file containing the source zip, which means you don't have to upload the same code for each different function. Not having something can make deployments unnecessarily long on OpenWhisk when you

Re: Pluggable Trigger Feed Event Provider

2019-03-15 Thread James Thomas
I've now opened an infrastructure ticket to move the pluggable event provider back into Apache OpenWhisk. https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-18011 Once this is done and the repo is ready, I'll work on migrating the S3 plugin back upstream too. On Sat, 9 Feb 2019 at 16:29, Rodric Rabbah

Re: override main on activation?

2019-03-15 Thread Michele Sciabarra
I like the idea. In particular, it would be very helpful in implementing an idea I had some time ago: deployment of Jupyter Notebooks as actions! (Here I refer to Python based notebooks mostly) Normally you have some code in it that you develop (and test) interactively, but the problem is:

[slack-digest] [2019-03-14] #random

2019-03-15 Thread OpenWhisk Team Slack
2019-03-14 03:00:14 UTC - Jin Choi: @Rodric Rabbah I am running Openwhisk system on my servers and here's one question for you. For Openwhisk deployment using ansible can we make it BLUE-GREEN deployment? Ansible playbooks in `${OPENWHISK_HOME}/ansible` doesn't seem so.

[slack-digest] [2019-03-14] #general

2019-03-15 Thread OpenWhisk Team Slack
2019-03-14 02:55:39 UTC - Rodric Rabbah: That suggests your controller didn’t come back cleanly. Checked the logs? In /tmp/wsklogs https://openwhisk-team.slack.com/archives/C3TPCAQG1/p1552532139263500?thread_ts=1552532139.263500=C3TPCAQG1 2019-03-14 03:01:46 UTC - Xue Shuai: @chetanm Thanks

fun contributor stats

2019-03-15 Thread Rodric Rabbah
The project has a total of 217 unique contributors across 32 repositories, and 145 of these are contributors to the "openwhisk" repo. There are (across all the repos): - 19 contributors with at least 100 commits - 7 contributors with at least 50 commits (and fewer than 100 commits) - 34